Re:Georgia Tech Student Indicted in UGA Hack
by boracay on Monday January 05, 2015 @07:35PM
(#8842252)
We'll have stupid laws as long as people who doesn't understand technology continue with those stupid analogy. Guess what, maybe defacing a calendar in the digital world is quite similar to, wait for it, defacing a calendar in the real world. No one is walking into anyone's home.
Re:Georgia Tech Student Indicted in UGA Hack
by rayiner on Monday January 05, 2015 @08:42PM
(#8842474)
Tech people think the problem is analogizing to the real world, because they see computer crimes as less serious than meat-space ones. But ordinary people see computer crimes as worse than analogous meat-space ones. The analogizing helps, not hurts. If you walked into someone's office (and a server can easily be as sensitive as someone's office or someone's desk), and just defaced their calendar, you'd be hit with a misdemeanor, under the corresponding Georgia law.
Re:Georgia Tech Student Indicted in UGA Hack
by waterlesscloud on Monday January 05, 2015 @08:46PM
(#8842479)
UGA has a law school, Tech doesn't. I think we know where the responsibility for bad Georgia laws lies. :-)
Re:Georgia Tech Student Indicted in UGA Hack
by mcmancini on Monday January 05, 2015 @10:00PM
(#8842698)
Emory?
Re:Georgia Tech Student Indicted in UGA Hack
by frogpelt on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @02:26PM
(#8846387)
Well put.
His post on the UGA website did not endanger anyone, did not incite riots or violence. It inconvenienced whoever had to fix it and it poked fun at the football team.
This would be like charging someone with grand larceny if they found a quarter on campus and put it in their pocket.
The definition of "computer trespass" isn't unreasonable. It should be illegal to break into a site and deface it, just as it should be illegal to walk into someone's house and put up a poster. People need to respect boundaries.
What's insane is that there's no gradations based on the seriousness of the conduct. Any crime punishable by a year or more in prison is a felony, and "computer trespass" is punishable by up to 15, even if the sentence is ultimately a slap on the wrist. In contrast, the meat-space equivalent of criminal trespass is a misdemeanor as long as any property damage is under $500: http://law.onecle.com/georgia/16/16-7-21.html. For more serious property damage, there is a separate statute, with different degrees of severity.