Let me reiterate since it seems that my message was a little unclear - the purpose of the medicine and finance analogy was say that even though there were many bogus financiers making false promises about their products by using simple models where they don't apply - this doesn't mean that there could never be non-bogus financiers that take a more rigorous and transparent approach to their use of models. We should demand the construction of financial instruments which cannot be "booby trapped". This is a case for more and better financial innovation, not less of it.
Of course this takes a broad view of financial innovation to include such things as auction design, election methods, etc.
I will also retract my statement that the valuation models were pseudo-science - to the extent that they made real predictions they were scientific. But they were undoubtedly cynically exploited.
Throughout history physics has had experiments whose results were incompatible with current models, which eventually lead to new theories (relativity, etc) but how do you know when contradicting information disproves your theory or will expand it.
Definition 1: A field that can't be can't make falsifiable predeictions. By this definitino, astrology is certainly a real science.
Definition 2: A field that makes false predictions. By this definition, most peoplle thing astrology is a pseudo-science.
If you're interested in this problem, this is a great reference: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/pseudo-science/
Uh, one thing to be careful with in such a statement is reasoning by analogy.
Consider if someone says:
"If physics can be made scientific, so can pertual-motion-machine-construction"
Or
"If chemistry can be made scientific, so can alchemy!"
Or
"If astronomy can be made scientific, so can astrology!"
The problem is clearer. Not every "field" is subject to valid innovation since some fields are inherently bogus. It is a hard problem determining which fields can "scientifized" so you might not be wrong. But I personally think that the real scientific economists are those that have argued that you're not ever going to find a "financial innovation" which adds value to the economy as a whole.