Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used
by seanflyon on Monday January 05, 2015 @07:16PM
(#8842173)
Most revenue means more than 50% of revenue, not all significant revue. If a work get 10% or 20% of its total revenue in its second decade than there is a significant increase in the incentive to create and publish if the creator owns that work for its second decade.
Again, I agree that Copyright lasts much too long. I was responding to the statement "no economic advantage of copyright after 5-10 years" (which it seems I misunderstood anyway, Houshalter replied that they were referring to no net economic benefit to society).
ISTR seeing that for the vast majority of works, most of the income ever earned for the copyright holder is earned within the first 5-7 years after creation.
Of course, some copyright holders have some works that are valuable longer, and use the proceeds from them to produce enough that they'll hit more of those jackpots (or can outright buy others.) But its not clear that supporting the ability to create those jackpots supports economic gains for society as a whole (rather than providing a gain for a minority of copyright holders at the expense of everyone else) or that it serves the constitutional purpose of copyright (which isn't to maximize rewards to creators, but to provide some reward to creators in order to "promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts".