> copyright has a clear boundary: you know whether you copied someone else's stuff
You can violate a copyrighted song by writing a song with a similar melody or motif. In the U.S., the accuser needs to prove that you previously heard the original song, but not that you were aware of the similarity or purposefully copied the musical idea.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used
by nullc on Saturday January 10, 2015 @09:38PM
(#8868812)
> the accuser needs to prove that you previously heard
Yes, indeed there are corner cases; and ugly outcomes. At the limit anyone can sue anyone for anything. But by broad strokes, both in theory and in practise the situation around copyright is far more clear, and appears to produce less collateral damage.
Imagine if you wanted to put an addition on your house and needed to file a multi-million dollar lawsuit that could stretch over a decade before you could determine whether it would cross your neighbor's property line.
[1] There's still some gray area around fair use, but the contrast with patents is night and day.