News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by AndrewKemendo on Monday January 05, 2015 @09:37AM (#8838943)
When we talk with investors one of the top questions is "What is your IP?" and that can mean a range of things but typically means "Do you have a patent?"

When we were starting out I did a lot of reading on patents, the system of patents litigation etc...and decided that the best thing for us would be to ignore the whole patent system and just push forward our technology into the marketplace hoping that we would be moving so quickly that trade secrets would keep us covered for the foreseeable future.

The thinking was: A patent only gives us the ability to argue our case for infringement in court. As a startup there is no possible way that we would be able to afford a lengthy IP court battle without serious VC money or revenue, at which point we should have been able to get the patent stuff figured out easily. Besides, a patent just tells the world how to do what you are doing which makes it easy to rip-off or change slightly as the ability to cover every single use case/implementation in a patent is basically impossible.

I still believe this, but we had so much pressure from investors (that usually didn't invest) that I spent a good 80+ hours writing/drawing our patent and getting the provisional done. Seemed like a good compromise.

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by DanBC on Monday January 05, 2015 @09:44AM (#8838974)
> Besides, a patent just tells the world how to do what you are doing which makes it easy to rip-off or change slightly as the ability to cover every single use case/implementation in a patent is basically impossible.

For an actual example of this see the hair removal device that used a rolling spring to rip out hair. Competitors realised they could do the same by using a set of wedged discs.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epilator. (See the "rotating disc" section).

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by throwawaykf05 on Monday January 05, 2015 @10:26AM (#8839242)
> As a startup there is no possible way that we would be able to afford a lengthy IP court battle without serious VC money or revenue...

This is essentially why many NPEs exist. You can approach them, and if they think your IP is being infringed by somebody worth suing, they will litigate it on "contingency". That is, they will charge you almost nothing but will keep the lion's share of any settlement or damages.

As bad as NPEs are when they target startups, they are often the only recourse when faced with a big, well-funded infringer. The current widespread negative rhetoric against "patent trolls" does well in distracting startups from this fact.

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by AndrewKemendo on Monday January 05, 2015 @10:40AM (#8839315)
This is a good point and was actually the argument that pushed me over the edge to actually doing it. The issue remains however that, even if our legal fees are paid for, the time and effort that goes into the defense is a HUGE distraction for an early stage company and enough to give the big company time to grab market share.