News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by Retric on Monday January 05, 2015 @09:37AM (#8838938)
Medical drug patents are arguably the best use case for patents and there doing exactly what they are intended. Remember the advantage of patents is what happens when they expire and we have a huge number 'generic' drug options cheaply available.

However, if you look at most fields (ex: engine design) they benifit from the same thing. In the end the real issue is new fields spend their first ~50 years in patent hell where the most obvious things are easily patented and you can't default to a 20 year old 'safe' design without major compromize.

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by bunderbunder on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:24AM (#8839546)
> Medical drug patents are arguably the best use case for patents and there doing exactly what they are intended.

Sort of. There's still a lot of rent-seeking. Consider this (egregiously) common pattern:

1. Release new wonder drug.

2. Rake in money until patent expires.

3. Make minor tweak to wonder drug, just enough that you can get a new patent.

4. Don't worry that this new version isn't as effective as the original. Just send armies of drug reps to badger doctors into prescribing it anyway. They'll go along with it; they don't have the time to read the medical literature and figure out for themselves that the old version with the expired patent is still a better drug.

5. GOTO 2

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by marcosdumay on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:53PM (#8840055)
#4 is because of a defective health-care system. No amount of patent reform can fix that.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by seanflyon on Monday January 05, 2015 @02:23PM (#8840579)
Another version of steps 3 and 4 is:

3. Discover that the same drug works for a different disease and patent the new application of the old drug.

4. Since the drug is still patented even after the original patent has expired, anyone making the drug still has to pay up even if they are selling it for the original, out of patent, use.

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by refurb on Monday January 05, 2015 @03:27PM (#8840921)
That's not true at all.

If you patent for disease A, then the patent expires, even if you patent for disease B, it doesn't stop anyone from making a generic version of your drug to treat disease A. Doctors will also prescribe that generic for disease B (there is nothing to stop them).

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by seanflyon on Monday January 05, 2015 @05:33PM (#8841692)
You are right. It seems the story I heard was an exaggeration of the bullying tactics a team of lawyers can perform.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by acgourley on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:31PM (#8839924)
Point 4 is hard to believe, and without it you're describing a well functioning system that promotes investment in new technology.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by UrMomReadsHN on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:33PM (#8840271)
Point 4 is known as "Evergreening" and it surely happens. An example I can think of off the top of my head is Lexapro.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by toomuchtodo on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:31PM (#8842934)
Pfizer tried to do this in Canada with Viagra, and the Canadian Supreme Court invalidated their patent in return.

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/11/pfizer-caught-gam...

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by crpatino on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:39PM (#8840312)
Even assuming point 4 does not hold up, the GP is describing a system that promotes arbitrarily long development cycles. i.e. if it takes 5 years to develop the next generation of a drug, but the patent expires after 20 years, you are basically rewarding the whole industry to do no more than 25-30% of technically feasible R&D.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by dragonwriter on Monday January 05, 2015 @09:48AM (#8838994)
> Medical drug patents are arguably the best use case for patents and there doing exactly what they are intended. Remember the advantage of patents is what happens when they expire and we have a huge number 'generic' drug options cheaply available.

What happens all too often when drug patents expire is that no one manufactures the drug at all, because the people with the capacity to do so get better returns manufacturing things that are still under patent (even if that's a newer but less effective treatment for the same condition, or even if it leaves no effective treatment for a condition available.)

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by geon on Monday January 05, 2015 @10:07AM (#8839127)
That makes bo sense. Why woul rhey abandon a working drug if no one else is interested in manufacturing a knock-off?
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by Kliment on Monday January 05, 2015 @10:20AM (#8839209)
The way it works is approximately this:

1. Your patent on drug A expires

2. You have an active patent monopoly on drug B which is functionally similar

3. You use your giant network of marketing staff to convince medical professionals to use B instead of A

4. The market for A collapses due to lack of demand.

The generics manufacturers cannot afford to spend nearly as much bribing doctors, so you don't get an equivalent demand push for generics unless one of the competing large pharma groups decide that the generic is profitable enough to counter the targeted campaign with a targeted campaign of their own. But why would they, when they can milk their own patent monopoly cashcows a bit more using the same marketing spend.

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by maxerickson on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:04AM (#8839432)
How dysfunctional are these doctors? I was in urgent care last week for a foot injury, and right on the wall in the exam room were some awareness posters about Ebola and antibiotics, yet every time a discussion of some awareness issue comes up, people talk about how doctors aren't even on top of things (maybe I'm stretching a bit to call generics vs marketed an awareness issue, but I don't think so).

(My foot is fine, I got a cold, yay hospitals)

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by damon_c on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:16AM (#8839494)
Programmer's inboxes are filled with emails from recruiters.

Doctor's inboxes are filled with emails from drug company reps offering to take them out to play golf and fancy dinners and give them boxes of free samples of the drugs made by the companies they rep. Those companies don't sell the low cost generics!

(source: a relative of mine is a drug company rep!)

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by maxerickson on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:45AM (#8839645)
That's what I meant by dysfunctional. Dinner with some boring company rep hardly sounds like something a person needs to do weekly.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by jblow on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:17PM (#8840181)
Do you think they hire boring people to be reps? If you were in charge of hiring the most effective people for this job, who would you hire?
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by logfromblammo on Monday January 05, 2015 @02:08PM (#8840506)
My replacement.

I'd want to hire people who are knowledgeable about pharmaceuticals and are able to accurately and intelligently answer questions about research studies and side effects. But an effective person would probably hire hot chicks and chatty dudes and give them big expense accounts.

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by seanp2k2 on Monday January 05, 2015 @02:06PM (#8840484)
Prostitutes and stand-up comedians. I'd also make an exclusive club at the airports for doctors who sell my drugs.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by damon_c on Monday January 05, 2015 @04:10PM (#8841174)
For the record, my relative is very good looking and fun to hang out with.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by Shinkei on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:54AM (#8839699)
Doctors are a heterogeneous mix just like people in any profession. There are good guys and bad guys... but nobody thinks that they are the bad guy. ;)
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by freehunter on Monday January 05, 2015 @10:56AM (#8839397)
Every insurance policy I've ever had has stipulated that if a generic is available, the insurance will not pay 100% for the brand name drug. Wouldn't that be enough to keep generics in business?
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by Kliment on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:12AM (#8839474)
This only applies if the active ingredient is the same molecule in the generic and the brand-name drug. Because drug B is has a patent monopoly scaring people off making generics, this is never the case.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by twoodfin on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:43AM (#8839635)
In 2012, 84% of dispensed drugs in the United States were generics.[1]

Yes, the original manufacturer often spends money to develop follow on versions that can qualify for new patents, but this isn't always an effective strategy. When it is, it's usually because the follow on version has substantial benefits for patients (e.g., monthly infusions at the doctor's office instead of weekly). If those benefits aren't there, insurers can and will decline to cover the new form of the drug and insist on the generic.

[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/19/business/use-of-generics-p...

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by logfromblammo on Monday January 05, 2015 @10:26AM (#8839243)
Because if they invest enough in marketing and regulatory compliance to keep it profitable, a generics manufacturer will immediately spin up and drink that milkshake.

If they abandon it, and no generic is produced, patients are forced to the patented alternatives.

The drug companies don't want to compete with their own products if they can avoid doing so.

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by arebop on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:26AM (#8839553)
I see discussion in this thread about what makes sense or seems reasonable, but no empirical observations. Two examples that come to my mind would be acetaminophen and coral snake antivenin. The former is widely available as a generic, the latter is extremely scarce in the U.S. in part because its manufacturer fears competition. Maybe someone can add more examples or help explain the different outcomes for these two?
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by dragonwriter on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:00PM (#8839734)
> Maybe someone can add more examples or help explain the different outcomes for these two?

The different outcomes are largely explained thus:

Drugs with a very large demand and especially ones which are OTC and around which consumer brands can be developed (where brand identity allows a premium to be charged, substituting in some degree for the monopoly rents patents allow) are likely to continue to be manufactured after patents expire. Prescription drugs with a limited demand even if they are the best (or only) effective treatment for a particular condition are less likely to continue to be produced once patent protection expires..

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by lotsofmangos on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:00AM (#8839414)
Pfizer has sent a letter out to people working in the NHS warning that they face legal consequences for prescribing an available generic version of pregabalin for pain relief, as although the initial patent for the drug has expired, there is a second patent on using the drug for pain.

So despite the fact that the generic is legally available within the NHS, Pfizer seems willing to chase doctors who prescribe it for pain relief.

http://boingboing.net/2014/12/24/pfizer-threatens-pharmacist...

(edited to make sense, thanks to jameshart)

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by jameshart on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:47AM (#8839658)
I try not to be picky about simple spelling and grammar issues online, but this is an important one: you mean prescribe, not proscribe. The meanings are almost opposite, so it matters more than most.

To prescribe is to define a desirable course of action. To proscribe is to define an undesirable course of action. Doctors prescribe medicines; laws proscribe crimes.

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by lotsofmangos on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:20PM (#8839843)
Oops, thanks for picking that up. I usually try and proofread my posts, but I missed that.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by Shinkei on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:51AM (#8839680)
This is a very complicated issue. I don't know laws/regulatory system in the UK, but in the States the FDA has to approve a medication for a specific indication. So if later people discover X drug is great for unapproved Y condition, then doctors have to prescribe it 'off-label.'

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Off-label_use

I don't know to what extent manufacturers can limit prescribing their branded drugs for off-label use. I feel like if I wrote a Rx for any drug for any indication, it would get filled without hassle... although if it was really outlandish, the Pharmacist would probably give me a call.

Source: I'm a doctor.

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by lotsofmangos on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:18PM (#8839830)
This isn't off-label use though. This is where the drug has been specifically approved for that use.

Pfizer here are not trying to limit prescribing their branded drugs for off-label use, they are trying to restrict the available uses of products that are legally supplied to the NHS by other companies.

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by UrMomReadsHN on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:43PM (#8840340)
I don't think the pharmacy knows your diagnosis when you fill a prescription. It isn't written on the prescription. You can in fact run into problems with the insurance company if the treatment is extremely expensive.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by DennisP on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:44AM (#8839640)
That's not the only way to fund drug development. For example, there was a bill in Congress a couple years ago to tax health insurance companies for development of patent-free drugs, using an X-Prize style system so it wouldn't be the government picking which research to fund.

The insurance companies get to spend less paying for treatment, and using the tax system gets around the public goods problem which prevents insurers from doing this voluntarily.

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by refurb on Monday January 05, 2015 @03:32PM (#8840955)
The insurance companies get to spend less paying for treatment, and using the tax system gets around the public goods problem which prevents insurers from doing this voluntarily.

That makes no sense. If you put a limit on potential returns by instituting a fixed "X-prize", why would companies continue to invest in R&D? Wouldn't they just pick the cheapest to develop drugs in order to maximize their return?

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by buttcoinslol on Monday January 05, 2015 @02:58PM (#8840753)
Who picks the research 'prizes'? Nominating prizes could be politicized, leading to government picking which research to fund.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by Houshalter on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:49PM (#8840028)
Medical research should really, really not be publicly funded. Say goodbye to anything remotely controversial. From life extension, to genetic engineering, to abortion and birth control, etc.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by pdabbadabba on Monday January 05, 2015 @04:09PM (#8841172)
I think this is a great point. Not sure why it's getting so many downvotes. Though I might quibble that medical research should not be exclusively government funded, or that it should not depend on government money. I'm OK with the government steering some extra money to the projects that need it (sometimes good social policy and private economic incentives don't align the way you'd like), but I agree a system where research is totally dependent on government money could be very bad.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by toomuchtodo on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:33PM (#8842939)
The NIH and its $30 billion a year in funding seem to be doing a fairly decent job.

http://www.nih.gov/about/budget.htm

Funding report by disease/research area:

http://report.nih.gov/categorical_spending.aspx

Note: Over a billion dollars a year is spent on stem cell research.

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by DennisP on Monday January 05, 2015 @04:53PM (#8841461)
The bill didn't outlaw pharmaceutical patents, it just provided an alternate funding mechanism that would produce drugs without patents. Any area the government wasn't funding would be the same as it is now.

We should at least publicly-fund antibiotics research, given that the current system is almost completely failing on that front.

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by Houshalter on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:46PM (#8840013)
Could we just move medical drugs to a different system? The majority of costs there isn't even inventing it, it's getting it tested and approved. It makes no sense for wildly different industries to use the same patent system.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by noobiemcfoob on Monday January 05, 2015 @01:24PM (#8840214)
I've never really considered a sort of distributed patent/copyright system before, one based on industry/products. You would likely run into issues about defining what is or isn't a new industry, but in general, I like the idea.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by tbrownaw on Monday January 05, 2015 @10:19AM (#8839204)
Aren't there problems when something potentially useful wouldn't be patentable (say, it's already known elsewhere) so there's no major profit in going thru the FDA approval process?

I'd think it would be better to tie the temporary exclusivity to who put it thru the approval process directly (and relax the restrictions a bit, but that's a separate issue...).

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by ScottBurson on Monday January 05, 2015 @04:03PM (#8841137)
> In the end the real issue is new fields spend their first ~50 years in patent hell where the most obvious things are easily patented

I think this is the most important part of your comment. How well patents work for drugs is a secondary question.

I would put it this way: the PTO has no good way of distinguishing mere novelty from nonobviousness. In a mature field, the two probably correlate pretty well: everything obvious will have been thought of. But in a young field, they don't. Specifically, when a new technology opens up new applications, those applications are often novel enough to be considered patentable, even when they are obvious to anyone who has the need that the application addresses.

When new technologies are extremely general, like personal computers and the Internet, this problem is at its worst: there are very large numbers of such new applications. And so we get lots of patent applications of the form "do X on a computer" or "do X over the Internet", and because those ideas are novel, as far as the PTO can tell, it assumes they are nonobvious.

The European patent court, as I understand, tries to address this problem by requiring that a patented invention demonstrate a "novel technical effect". I think this is a good idea: it attempts to distinguish inventions that are truly new technology from those that are simply novel applications of technology, the implication being that the latter are more likely to be obvious, even though novel. In fact, I think this is a much better approach than the one the US Supreme Court took in the recent Alice decision [0], in which they rejected a patent for being about an "abstract idea". Both approaches require the PTO to make a judgment, but the question of whether an invention is an "abstract idea" seems to me much harder to pin down (what's a non-abstract idea?) than that of whether it contributes to technology or merely uses technology. (Though I wouldn't say the latter question is always going to be trivial.)

Another thing I would like to see is heavier and more consistent reliance on what are called the "Graham factors" [1], particularly those that show objective evidence of nonobviousness: commercial success; long-felt but unsolved needs; and failure of others to solve the same problem. I would go so far as to say that the presumption, particularly in a young field, should be that an invention, notwithstanding its novelty, should be considered to be obvious unless the applicant can demonstrate some objective evidence that it isn't.

[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice_Corp._v._CLS_Bank_Interna... [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inventive_step_and_non-obviousn...