News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by Spooky23 on Monday January 05, 2015 @09:28AM (#8838900)
People and companies always want a competitive advantage, often at the expense of the industry as a whole.

Why is it "bad" if patents are the reason things are held up, but "not bad" if it's a common trade secret or proprietary application? Didn't Google hold back the entire industry by not making their secret sauce for large scale management of IT infrastructure broadly available?

IMO, the patent problem is a scoping problem -- we allow patents that aren't appropriate. The concept of patents makes it possible to make large capital investments to actually invent things. We need that imo.

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by geon on Monday January 05, 2015 @10:24AM (#8839228)
Most patents seems to be the logical conclusion of trying to solve some problem. Anyone else who has the same problem will reach a similar solution. It is "simply" a matter of doing the engineering. A patent would forbid anyone else from even trying.

The Google infrastructure would be a good example. Amazon and Facebook have built similar facilities.

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by pjc50 on Monday January 05, 2015 @10:47AM (#8839349)
Trade secrets and proprietary applications can be independently re-invented.
Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by Spooky23 on Monday January 05, 2015 @11:38AM (#8839620)
That's exactly the issue that the previous poster brought up -- with a patent, the "secret sauce" is public. The lessons learned by Google all need to be re-learned again and again, which slows progress for industry as a whole.

In the pharmaceutical case, generic manufacturers are often able to start producing a medicine on the day the patent expires. In the Google/trade secret case, the world may forever lose valuable tools and techniques that are kept proprietary once, but cease being useful to Google.

Re:Almost No Patented Discoveries Get Used by pjc50 on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:35PM (#8839945)
It seems the usefulness of this varies from field to field. It's generally easier to reverse engineer software from binaries or even rewrite it from a plain English description than it is to reverse engineer the patents.

Whether it "slows progress" has got to be an empirical question with results that vary from field to field. The "with patents" case in software forces not only rediscovery but reinvention and engineering around patents (which exists in the pharma case as well).

Now, a software patent system that involved filing a copy of the source code with the patent? That would be a great way of preserving tools in the public record. But that's not how it works at the moment.