The evidence for it to extend healthy, mean, and maximum life span in a wide range of species is very extensive: mice, flies, nematodes, etc, etc, etc. The primate evidence for life span extension is mixed at this time, partially because the two decades-long studies were poorly designed in hindsight, and the expectation is that it doesn't extend life greatly in humans. Nonetheless, it has enormously impressive short term health effects in we primates [1]. If calorie restriction was a pill rather than a lifestyle, you'd beat a path to the manufacturer's door, as it has far greater positive effects on health for basically healthy people than any presently available medical technology.
It is true that there is some concern in the research community over the degree to which laboratory mice are not good reflections of what is being studied. This is not unknown, and it is not unacknowledged. A range of rigorous testing programs aim to do something about past less rigorous results - see for example the NIA Interventions Testing Program [2].
Interestingly it is worthy of note that many past research programs were tainted by inadvertent calorie restriction - the things they tested led to led to lab animals eating less. The effects of calorie restriction on health and life span are many times larger than those produced by most other things under testing.
To address your subtext of animal abuse, the only thing worse than running animal studies to advance medicine and life science knowledge is to not run those studies. Even the path to the future in which near all studies are carried out in tissue engineered flesh or simulation, causing no harm to creatures capable of suffering, requires present animal studies. Researchers want that future as it is better on all counts. Further, studies of calorie restriction and longevity are about the most benign of animal studies: these animals are healthier and longer-lived as a result of the restriction. If you want to do something about animal suffering, farming is the place to start, not research, as it accounts for 99.9% of the harms you dislike.
[1]: http://impactaging.com/papers/v5/n7/full/100581.html
[2]: http://www.nia.nih.gov/research/dab/interventions-testing-pr...
It seems that excess of calories have a big negative effect for an "idle/aged" lifestyle, and almost no effect for "hyper-active/young" lifestyle.
It seems also related to urban vs. rural populations.
The fear is that when we use animal models the interventions we find in them will not apply to humans because we are already utilising these strategies naturally. For example, the level of Uric acid in humans is very high, so high that it tends to precipitate out in the extremities causing gout. One theory of why we have such high levels of Uric acid in our bloodstream is because it is protecting us from age related damage - it is one of the simple 'hacks' that we use to age slowly.
Getting to your question there is some concern that calorie restriction won't work in humans for the same reason - we are already using the same pathways activated by calorie restriction in lab animals.
Anyway I cut down to one day a week, which is far more manageable (I am pretty skinny, and I was struggling to keep my weight up). Now it feels good. I have a feeling it is to do with insulin sensitivity, as I no longer feel hunger pangs, and don't get the sleepy feeling after having a huge lunch.
So yes, I consider myself reasonably healthy, but even so I had blood pressure and cholesterol that were bordering between normal and high levels.
IF is about managing appetite mostly, as the hormone that plays a large role in driving hunger (ghrelin) is highly habitual; the more often you eat, the more often you're going to be hungry. So by reducing the time-window in which you eat, you reduce the window when you'll feel hungry, which can dramatically aid diet adherence.
But that's more the everyday form of IF. If you're on a eat-stop-eat type protocol and fast once or twice a week, you're probably using it to ensure you maintain a caloric deficit each week. You're bundling all your reduction in food consumption into one day a week instead of ensuring you're at TDEE-400 calories every day.
Now I kind of enjoy it (one day a week). I occasionally stop, i.e. on holiday, and I do notice a bit of lethargy creeping in a time to time.
Otherwise, just get a cookbook and go for recipes that are less than 600 calories (that's the total I allow my self on a fast day).
Should have the same health test in March, so hopefully one day a week is still doing well (I have a blood pressure monitor to check that and and mine still down, actually it improved when I went from 2 to 1 day a week, maybe because I was eating a lot of crap to try and keep my weight up).
Have a google about for BBC's Horizon "Eat fast live longer". I can't find a full length version on youtube just now, but I am sure it is somewhere on the web. That's what inspired me.
I personally avoid exercise on the fast days, but some people swear by it (reddit has some subs on keto diet, which I think is combining exercise fasting and diet), but I am probably in a minority that I am not trying to loose weight with it.
Actually in the afternoon / evening it feels a lot like you have been on a long hike or something similar - probably due to using up your blood glycogen. You likely wouldn't really want to go to the gym after that.
But it seems that it is one extreme case. Another extreme would be stories about wandering (note that "wandering") Indian ascetics, who had very modest and not regular meals (low calories, not abundant) but display a very good fitness (compared to average consumers).
The truth is still out there.)
See for a very good review: http://jn.nutrition.org/content/137/4/1078.full
But I do acknowledge your underlying point -- that it is exceedingly difficult to know how well results from mouse studies can be generalized to humans. It is a big problem.
The problem is that animals in laboratories are "coach potatoes". They don't do the exercise they naturally do in their habitat searching for food.
They live overcrowded in small cages and overstressed. Most lab animals are already ill from their artificial habitat, they have diabetes and other disorders.
Strong social animals are isolated so they don't create problems like fighting each other(what are thy going to do if not?).
Imagine you were forced to live in a sofa, or in your bed, all your life, with no sunlight but LED lighting.
Most of those animals are overeating for their activity, so making them starve is better than not doing it. But this tells us nothing about real animals in the real world.
http://www.vivisectioninformation.com/index.php?p=1_27_Unrep...