News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientists are suggesting that depression is a result of ... by phkahler on Sunday January 04, 2015 @09:27PM (#8836824)
>> You are getting down-voted because Paleo is not scientific.

Weather or not the basis of Paleo is sound is not relevant to his point. Not only does he claim benefits for himself, but notes that others seem to agree in similar ways.

I'm really getting pissed at the commercial medial establishment for denying anything that doesn't have clinical trial can be good. Plants or minerals that have helped people for thousands of years are called "homeopathic" or "alternative" by real doctors. Now we're seeing studies that claim various things have no benefit "for people on an already healthy diet" as a footnote. Yet good old aspirin is a plant derivative, as are some other things. But I digress. His point is independent of the basis for the diet and hence should not be downvoted for that.

Re:Scientists are suggesting that depression is a result of ... by dalke on Sunday January 04, 2015 @11:33PM (#8837297)
We also have centuries of history which show that practices people thought were good actually did nothing, or made things worse. People got better despite the treatment, which caused them to believe that the treatment was the success.

It took over 1,000 years for the humorism of Ancient Greece to be discarded as wrong, and Hippocrates' theories on bloodletting, once a mainstay of medicine, to be relegated to only a few modern uses.

Mercury has been a part of traditional medicines for thousands of years across Eurasia. "There is hardly a disease in the nosology for which mercury in some form has not been used." "No doubt many patients died after years of suffering from slow mercurial poisoning." (Quotes from http://www.soilandhealth.org/02/0201hyglibcat/020134syphilis... ) .

While mercury still has some medical uses, the fact is that centuries of reports claimed wide benefits and successes for mercury is evidence that claiming benefits for oneself, and the agreement of others, is not strong evidence that it actually is good. It may be good, but it isn't sufficient. It may actually be bad.

There's also drugs which we know are effective, but which are usually riskier and less effective than other drugs. Eg, sulfa drugs vs. beta-lactams. While treating with sulfa drugs absolutely has benefits, promoting it over other, better possibilities leads to overall worse healthcare. That's why sulfas aren't a first line drug any more.

In terms of a Paleo diet, it may be good, or not, or it may be that other diets are better.

How do you know which it is? How do you know which traditional uses of mercury are toxic? Which traditional uses of bloodletting are worse than not doing bloodletting at all? We only have three solutions: trials (which gives the clearest evidence when done right), epidemiology (much harder to interpret), and mechanistic (there's no reason to believe that a leg amputation will help a cold, and the best case outcome quite severe, making it unethical to test that experimentally. This is mostly used to reject unlikely possibilities which have poor evidence backing it.)

Re:Scientists are suggesting that depression is a result of ... by tinco on Sunday January 04, 2015 @10:27PM (#8837032)
> Plants or minerals that have helped people for thousands of years are called "homeopathic" or "alternative" by real doctors.

No, homeopathic medicin is called homeopathic by real doctors. Homeopathy is not ancient, it was invented in 1796. It also does not involve plants of any kind.

Plants that do help or seem to help and have been in use for hundreds or thousands of years are only called alternative when there either has not been research to show that they are effective, or there has been research that shows they are not effective.

Alternative does not necessarily mean bad. The word is merely used as a way to distinguish unproven medicine from scientifically proven medicine.

Re:Scientists are suggesting that depression is a result of ... by dllthomas on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:19AM (#8837430)
While I think the parent comment does not understand what "homeopathic" means, I don't think it's correct that "[homeopathy] does not involve plants of any kind." My understanding is that the "active" ingredients are often plant based - after all, it was cinchona overdose that started this mess. If that's the case, homeopathic remedies don't contain the plants anymore (through over-dilution), but homeopathy as a process involves plants.
Re:Scientists are suggesting that depression is a result of ... by UrMomReadsHN on Monday January 05, 2015 @12:16AM (#8837417)
You really want to go back to the days before evidence based medicine? Really?

Nobody is "denying anything that doesn't have clinical trial can be good." Hardly. It is more like "these people say this is good, now lets prove it." Do we nees more medicinal research? Yes. Is there a billion things we don't understand or know yet? Yes. That doesn't mean we don't learn.

Re:Scientists are suggesting that depression is a result of ... by phkahler on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @11:07AM (#8844953)
>> You really want to go back to the days before evidence based medicine? Really?

No, quite the opposite. But I also want people to stop rejecting things due to lack of evidence. If individuals or groups of people claim a benefit from something, why should that be rejected without proper investigation?

I stand by my claim that Iodine and Magnesium cured my asthma and I have test data to back it up. Will it work for you? I dunno. But your doctor is unlikely to recommend it and no company is going to do clinical trials.

Re:Scientists are suggesting that depression is a result of ... by DiabloD3 on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @11:38AM (#8845222)
What you did is called a n=1 study. Since Big Pharma doesn't want to fund research into things they can't profit from, n=1 studies is all we have to understand the science of the human body a lot of the time. Its better than doing things blind.
Re:Scientists are suggesting that depression is a result of ... by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 06, 2015 @11:50AM (#8845320)
>> You really want to go back to the days before evidence based medicine? Really?

> No, quite the opposite. But I also want people to stop rejecting things due to lack of evidence.

Science-based medicine is rejecting positive claims when there is insufficient evidence to reject the null hypothesis. You can't claim that you want the oppose of abandoning evidence based medicine and simultaneously claim you want people to stop rejecting things due to lack of evidence.

> If individuals or groups of people claim a benefit from something, why should that be rejected without proper investigation?

There's a difference between rejecting something as a justified claim and rejecting it as a hypothesis for which there may be reason for further investigation -- the former is warranted more often than the latter, though even the latter can be warranted when, in addition to a lack of evidence for the claimed causal mechanism, there is a lack of evidence for the phenomenon it explains, or where there is evidence for the phenomenon but there is also sufficient evidence to conclude that an alternative cause to the proposed one was at work.

n=1 studies of treatments for medical conditions frequently suffer from either or both of these problems; particularly the first, as they generally lack sufficient evidence that improvement outside of the range plausible without any intervention occurred.

> I stand by my claim that Iodine and Magnesium cured my asthma and I have test data to back it up.

As iodine deficiency depresses immune function and asthma symptoms are commonly triggered by respiratory infections (either alone or in combination with other environmental factors), I don't think anyone concerned with evidence-based medicine would be surprised that there are people for whom increasing iodine intake reduced or eliminated asthma symptoms. Iodine also has other well-established effects that relate directly to known risk factors for asthma.

> But your doctor is unlikely to recommend it and no company is going to do clinical trials.

Sure, your doctor is unlikely, absent other evidence indicative of an iodine deficiency, to conclude that your asthma is due to an iodine deficiency and recommend that as an appropriate intervention. Because its not particularly likely to be true or an effective intervention.

OTOH, with symptoms that are more closely tied to an iodine deficiency, they are likely to test for that (and with test results showing such a deficiency, they are likely to recommend iodine to correct it.)

I imagine similar things are generally true of magnesium.