Yeah, it's true that you can't outright buy an election wholesale. But rich people are rich for a reason: they don't just throw their money away on things that have zero results. They spend so much on elections because it has real results. Maybe it sways a race by 4%. But if the race is decided by 2%, then that's enough to win instead of lose. Plus, some of that money goes to campaigning, some goes to decide which candidates are able to afford to run in the first place, some goes to lobbyists, some of it goes directly to congressmen in return for favors, etc.
"Economic Inequality and Political Representation", Dr. Larry Bartels, Princeton https://www.princeton.edu/~bartels/economic.pdf
“Economic elites and organized groups representing business interests have substantial independent impacts on U.S. government policy, while average citizens and mass-based interest groups have little or no independent influence.”
~ Martin Gilens and Benjamin Page, Testing Theories of American Politics: Elites, Interest Groups, and Average Citizens; Perspectives on Politics, 2014
In my opinion yes, simply because I feel the "raw $$$ given away" metric is inherently useless when attempting to measure generosity; Exactly because it doesn't factor income into the equation. Someone making $1 million annually could give 100% (or more) of a lower income individual's income away without any serious effect on his quality of life.
A d of course high income folks pay 10-20% more of their income in taxes than low income folks.
And quite possibly spend more supporting extended family members and friends , compared to lower income members of the same family or social circle.
This is blatantly false. The effective tax rates for the super rich are much lower than the average person, due to the majority of their income coming from capital gains. For example, Mitt Romney paid 14% on the 13.7M he made[1] in 2011.
[1] http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2012/09/21/mitt_romney_s...
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_tax_in_the_United_States...
Are you arguing that we should remove the tax break given to charitable donations?
"Another study, by a coalition of nonprofits called the Independent Sector, revealed that people with incomes below twenty-five grand give away, on average, 4.2 percent of their income, while those earning more than 150 grand a year give away only 2.7 percent."
This study is also unconvincing. You could say by percent the people making less than $25k are more generous, but the use of percents as a metric here is misleading. 2.7% of $150k+ is a minimum of $4050 while 4.2% of <$25k is at most $1050. Is it fair to say the wealthy are less generous when they are donating more money by one metric but not another?