Re:The Anti-Tolkien
by wpietri on Saturday January 03, 2015 @01:34PM
(#8831539)
I'd happily believe that he wasn't consciously racist. But I'd find it hard to believe he had no racial bias; even today things like Project Implicit show most people as biased, and he grew up in a very different era.
But still, I think the way he exaggerates various human race and class characteristics into Essentially Different Peoples and then puts together a giant race war is problematic as anything other than light entertainment. Great battles of Good vs Evil are fine for kids' stories and escapist fantasy, but I think Moorcock and others are spot on that it's troubling to the extent that people take it more seriously.
But still, I think the way he exaggerates various human race and class characteristics into Essentially Different Peoples and then puts together a giant race war is problematic as anything other than light entertainment. Great battles of Good vs Evil are fine for kids' stories and escapist fantasy, but I think Moorcock and others are spot on that it's troubling to the extent that people take it more seriously.