News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by kazinator on Friday January 02, 2015 @05:18PM (#8828888)
The thing is, nothing you can discover in physics can refute the multiverse hypothesis. It is not falsifiable in that way.

Even if you find that you're in a very special universe, you need an explanation of why it is that way. The multiverse hypothesis helps, by giving a plausible answer which avoids belief in gods.

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by dragonwriter on Friday January 02, 2015 @06:50PM (#8829236)
> Even if you find that you're in a very special universe, you need an explanation of why it is that way.

Emotionally "need", perhaps. Scientifically, not really.

> The multiverse hypothesis helps, by giving a plausible answer which avoids belief in gods.

The multiverse conjecture is -- by your own description -- not a hypothesis in the scientific sense, because, as you say, it cannot be falsified empirically. Like any belief in God that is compatible with science, its simply -- from a scientific perspective -- superfluous. It has no advantage, except the emotional advantage it provides to someone with an emotional bias to (1) have an explanation even if it is untestable, and (2) to avoid that explanation relying on belief in God.

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by stefantalpalaru on Friday January 02, 2015 @05:49PM (#8829010)
> The multiverse hypothesis helps, by giving a plausible answer which avoids belief in gods.

But as long as there is no proof of the existence of these multiple universes it's still magical thinking.

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by AnimalMuppet on Friday January 02, 2015 @06:44PM (#8829211)
Worse: Why do you consider the multiple universe hypothesis as more probable than the God hypothesis?

On the basis of data? No. (If you think otherwise, show us the data.)

On the basis of philosophical prejudice? Yes, I think that's the reason.

But if you say that, given no evidence for God, one should be an atheist, then given no evidence for multiple universes...

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by kazinator on Friday January 02, 2015 @07:19PM (#8829318)
Philosophical prejudice in favor of "no hidden variables".

Even the hypothesis that this is the only universe requires hidden variables (to explain what snuffs out the other universes, setting up this one as the one and only).

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by AnimalMuppet on Friday January 02, 2015 @07:59PM (#8829474)
But aren't other universes also "hidden variables"?

Even more, why do you say "to explain what snuffs out the other universes"? That means you're already assuming that there are (or were or should be) other universes. What is your basis for assuming that?

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by kazinator on Friday January 02, 2015 @10:48PM (#8829866)
It's the same basis like for the notion that, for instance, there is no greatest integer.

It would be surprising if suddenly the integers stopped at a particular value. Such an extraordinary situation would require an extraordinary explanation.

Any set of rules you can imagine gives you a universe. If you say that there is only this universe and nothing else, then you're denying the existence of things like the complex plane.

Or else you're asserting that the physical world exists in a different sense.

But so far, all evidence points toward the world being nothing but math.

Not a single discovery in physics has ever been anything other than math: a mathematical relationship (equations) or a quantity (constant).

Maybe that's just a "streak" of a particular kind of luck: maybe the next discovery will be of something non-mathematical. I'm betting on it being "math all the way down".

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by stefantalpalaru on Saturday January 03, 2015 @08:10AM (#8830660)
> Any set of rules you can imagine gives you a universe.

That's like saying that any supernatural being you can imagine gives you a god. Reality is not the consequence of math and it is absurd to believe that things exist just because you had some results from an equation.

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by kazinator on Saturday January 03, 2015 @01:27PM (#8831512)
> it is absurd to believe that things exist just because you had some results from an equation.

Okay, so then: what has advancement in physics ever given us, other than yet another equation or a numeric constant?

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by kazinator on Friday January 02, 2015 @08:08PM (#8829504)
Other universes aren't hidden variables because they have no effect. That is to say, no process in one universe is postulated to explain a process in another universe (because any such a bridge would mean that we are really talking about the same universe, right?)