News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by Steuard on Friday January 02, 2015 @03:21PM (#8828325)
I used to believe that the history of physics gave unwavering evidence that there is always a deep reason for the patterns and phenomena we observe: maybe not for the specifics of everyday life, but certainly for fundamental facts. (Think of how atomic theory made sense of the elements, or how nuclear physics explained how the sun could shine for so long, or how the unification of electricity and magnetism miraculously turned out to explain optics as well.) So I was convinced that we would someday find a fundamental theory that would be able to predict things like the fine structure constant or the charge to mass ratio of the electron.

But eventually someone pointed out that before we understood the history and nature of the solar system, natural philosophers looked for similarly deep explanations for the orbits of the planets. Kepler once proposed a deep connection between the (five) gaps between the six known planets and the five platonic solids (see, e.g. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/blogs/physics/2011/12/beautiful...), and Bode's law for planetary orbits was widely accepted until Neptune was discovered in the "wrong" place in 1846 (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Titius%E2%80%93Bode_law).

Today, we understand that there is no reason to expect any particular pattern of planetary orbits: solar systems are a dime a dozen in the galaxy, and their details are accidents of history. So while I don't like the idea, I've gradually come to accept that the "fundamental physical constants" of our universe could conceivably turn out to be just as arbitrary as the ratio of Jupiter's major orbital axis to Saturn's.

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by placebo on Friday January 02, 2015 @04:30PM (#8828665)
Not sure this analogy holds. Although the ratio of Jupiter's and Saturn's major orbital axis might seem arbitrary, given all the prior conditions to the orbit formations, current physics theories perhaps could have theoretically predicted this ratio long before it came to be. In the same way, physicists would like an elegant model that would predict or explain the constants in a way that makes more sense in a larger picture rather than having them as some magic numbers.
Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by Steuard on Friday January 02, 2015 @04:43PM (#8828722)
Exactly. That's pretty much what multiverse models suggest might be true for "fundamental constants": if you somehow knew the precise conditions of our part of the universe in the moments leading up to our big bang (and the parameters of whatever process triggered it: quantum fluctuations or whatever), you could in principle predict things like the charge to mass ratio of the electron. (E.g. if you knew the precise shape and fluxes of our 6-dimensional Calabi-Yau compactification manifold in string theory, you could work out the low-energy field content and coupling constants of the resulting universe.)

[String phenomenology isn't really my field, but I certainly haven't had a lot of luck deriving a unique background from pure theory. I did once think that I'd found a model that predicted the cosmological constant to within an order of magnitude or two, but that obviously didn't pan out.]

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by rndn on Friday January 02, 2015 @06:57PM (#8829254)
That’s the idea of an infinite number of onion layers [1]. What I find intriguing is that if you assume that everything is based on cause and effect, then (I think) you necessarily run into an infinite regress problem (the cause of a cause of a cause …) unless you define some "uncaused cause", or the concept of causation breaks down at some point.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_everything#Infinite_...

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by JadeNB on Friday January 02, 2015 @07:17PM (#8829312)
> What I find intriguing is that if you assume that everything is based on cause and effect, then (I think) you necessarily run into an infinite regress problem (the cause of a cause of a cause …) unless you define some "uncaused cause", or the concept of causation breaks down at some point.

Another possible resolution is a cyclic picture (something like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyclic_model), in which the cause of the cause of the cause of … may be the original event.

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by hasenj on Friday January 02, 2015 @07:49PM (#8829430)
Cyclic causality is even more troublesome than infinite regress.

I find myself leaning towards causation breaking down at some point. Just like our concepts of "position" and "momentum" break down at the quantum level.

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by noobermin on Friday January 02, 2015 @08:00PM (#8829479)
You say that causa sui or at least cyclic cause is troublesome without saying why. I'm curious for your reasoning.
Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by rndn on Friday January 02, 2015 @07:28PM (#8829354)
Isn’t that an infinite regress problem?
Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by JadeNB on Friday January 02, 2015 @08:47PM (#8829604)
> Isn’t that an infinite regress problem?

I can certainly see the sense in which it might be said to be, but I think that's not the sense in which the term is originally meant. I tried to come up with an explanation of why I think they were meaningfully different by an appeal to mathematical analogy, but I'm not sure that it's convincing.

Fermat argued as follows: a positive integer solution to `x^4 + y^4 = z^4` could always be converted into a smaller such solution, and you can't produce ever-smaller positive integers forever, so there weren't any such solutions in the first place. I'd say that this is clearly an infinite regress (though it was actually called infinite descent).

On the other hand, consider the problem of subtracting 1. In the system of ordinary (not-necessarily-positive) integers, this leads to a (non-paradoxical) infinite regress; whereas, in the system of integers modulo some fixed positive integer, it leads to a (non-paradoxical) circularity (where repeatedly subtracting 1 from a number will eventually yield that number itself). I think that it is reasonable to call these different phenomena.

Re:Complications in Physics Lend Support to Multiverse Hypot... by Steuard on Friday January 02, 2015 @10:36PM (#8829833)
I certainly didn't intend to suggest that an infinite number of theoretical layers might be necessary to explain nature (though I suppose I can't rule it out). Everything in my comment was meant to be compatible with (to take one example) the possibility that some particular well-defined refinement of string theory turns out to be the ultimate theory of nature, and only variations in local conditions are unpredictable. (This is meant in much the same way that the well established laws of gravitation, electromagnetism, and nuclear physics will give rise to very diverse solar systems.)

There are interesting questions in many multiverse models about the history and origin of the universe, and I've seen people express concerns about the possibility of "infinite history" in much the same words you've used here. But that's a different issue than Smolin's notion of infinitely many layers of theory being needed to keep the cosmic machinery running.

Personally, I'm not overly bothered by the notion of space and time existing forever in both directions, with new bubbles of interesting reality occasionally spawning themselves from the remnants of the old ones at random after uncounted eons of darkness. I don't know why that structure might exist rather than something else (or why there is something rather than nothing), but positing a "first cause" wouldn't make me any more satisfied (and would raise additional questions). I think modern math and science are more comfortable with the possibility of infinity than folks used to be, and that our notion of a "cause" is rather different. (When I think of "causality", all I think about are light cones and Cauchy problems: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cauchy_problem .)