> It makes me wonder if Moorcock has ever actually read Tolkien.
Probably he just didn't read it thoroughly enough. Recent writers put characterization and moral ambiguities at the forefront of their stories, like Moorcock wanted. Tolkien (and the pre-modern works he imitated) put those elements in the background and make the reader dig them out.
Agreed about Jack Vance. I recommend Eyes of the Overworld/Cugel the Clever.
What I find so facinating about this is 'complex' charaters in modern fiction are really a dumbing down of the art form.
I think if you've gotten to the point where you have to assume ignorance in somebody obviously well read just to feel right, you've made a mistake.
If you want a modern fictional take, try Richard Morgan's stuff. He shares Moorcock's suspicion of power and antipathy to Tolkein's reactionary political leanings. And he likewise avoids Tolkein's indulgence of Manichean ethical notions.
Re:The Anti-Tolkien
by lobster_johnson on Friday January 02, 2015 @01:59PM
(#8827971)
Gene Wolfe is fantastic. The Book of the New Sun deconstructed the fantasy genre decades before G. R. R. Martin, in a much more sophisticated way than Moorcock. Unfortunately Wolfe has a much smaller readership, undeservedly so.
LOTR was written against the backdrop of Hitler, Stalin, Mussolini, and a world where good and evil didn't seem very ambiguous, yet think about how many times this ambiguity comes up: Gollum. Good or evil? Saruman? Boromir? There is nothing childish or "Pooh-like" about these characters. They are very real, very intense confrontations with good and evil. Even Bilbo and Frodo themselves struggle with this. We assume the ring has the power to corrupt, but is the ring truly doing the corrupting, or is this lust for power something innate within that the ring simply exploits for its own purposes?
And what defines true power? Is it the ring itself? Is it the one who carries it? Frodo and Sam, two of the smallest of the races of Middle-Earth manage to bring down the most powerful of enemies with little more than courage and a desire to do what's right, while the powerful (the humans of Rohan and Gondor) quibble amongst themselves and their leaders are easily manipulated or go mad with sorrow and fear.
Long story short, I think Moorcock is wrong. I find the idea of a drug-addicted elf more ridiculous than anything Tolkien ever wrote. It's as though Moorcock defines fantasy as merely a setting through which he can play out his literary amibitions. That isn't to say there's anything wrong with a drug-addicted elf, it's just that drug addiction -- a so-called "real" problem to Tolkien's alleged "Pooh" problems -- does not alone elevate one's work to higher stature, nor should it be used a bludgeon to demote the work of others. I have learned far more about life and human nature from Tolkien than I have from Moorcock, and Tolkien's work was more entertaining too.
EDIT: Oh, and if you want to read some incredibly clever and unique sci-fi/fantasy, check out anything by Gene Wolfe or Jack Vance. Wolfe's Book of the New Sun is brilliant, and Vance's Lyonesse trilogy is amazing.