News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Anti-Tolkien by JoshTriplett on Friday January 02, 2015 @03:00AM (#8825981)
I certainly agree that Tolkein, along with quite a lot of other fantasy, has the concept of "good" and "evil" peoples, which is rather simplistic. That said, I have a hard time seeing "all orcs/trolls are evil" as an analogue for real-world racism, especially since not all humans/dwarves/hobbits/elves are good. You could perhaps make a case for such stories encouraging such simplistic thinking and classification elsewhere, though. It's certainly not subtle by any means.

To your other point, though: in various parts of the stories, there are good and evil humans, good and evil hobbits, good and evil dwarves, good and evil Ainur (Wizards), and good and evil elves. Also look at Gollum's backstory, and look at the rather gray morality of various self-serving folks towards the end of The Hobbit. As for "dark and ugly", there are plenty of evils throughout Tolkein that contradict one or both of those: Saruman, Denethor, Grima, Lotho, Smaug, Gollum, the Balrog, to some extent the Wood Elves, the Nazgul.

By comparison, if you want to see what racism in fantasy looks like, look at Tolkein's contemporary, Lewis, and his Calormene, or Lovecraft's...well, everything.

Re:The Anti-Tolkien by wtbob on Friday January 02, 2015 @11:44AM (#8827407)
> By comparison, if you want to see what racism in fantasy looks like, look at Tolkein's contemporary, Lewis, and his Calormene…

I don't believe that there was anything racist in Lewis's attitude to the Calormenes. They weren't inherently evil people, although their culture was in most parts bad and in some parts evil. Note the young Calormene Emeth who is saved in The Last Battle.

Re:The Anti-Tolkien by akanet on Friday January 02, 2015 @05:09AM (#8826273)
I agree with your analysis. I think a lot of people in this thread have objected to my comments on the assumption that I am making a strong claim of racism against Tolkein. I really meant it when I said casual undertones. Would that Tolkein existed in a vacuum, this would be largely inconsequential, it's just that his blueprint has become the prototype for the whole genre.

There are certainly characters in Tolkein who have less black-and-white moralities, but you very quickly see that "goodness" varies as a spectrum along "race" in LOTR.

I certainly agree that other authors are more racist.