News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The two cultures of mathematics and biology by pvaldes on Wednesday December 31, 2014 @11:26PM (#8822155)
In fact is not related with mathematics or biology. Is just a literary problem. They are not paying enough attention to the inner flow of their work.

An example:

"This is the field where one STUDIES the locus of

solutions of

sets of

polynomial equations

by combining the algebraic properties of

the rings of

polynomials with

the geometric properties of

this locus,

known as a variety.

Traditionally, this HAD MEANT complex solutions of

polynomials with

complex coefficients but

just prior to Grothendieck's work,

Andre Weil and Oscar Zariski HAD REALIZED that

much more scope and insight WAS GAINED by

considering solutions and

polynomials over

arbitrary fields,

e.g. finite fields or

algebraic number fields."

........ This is "almost lisp code" in its structure.

The inner flow here is really dislocated here with all those interruptions and changes of direction and meaning. There is also a problem with the timeline. They talk in the same paragraph about at least four, maybe five different moments in time, shown in this order: 5,1,4,3 and maybe 2 (being 1 the oldest and 5 the current time). This is driving to distraction to the reader probably (I find it pretty annoying at least)

Re:The two cultures of mathematics and biology by UhUhUhUh on Wednesday December 31, 2014 @11:45PM (#8822185)
That's a good point. It seems to be very difficult for mathematicians to formulate their thoughts in a non-formal manner. When they try to, it's almost like they speak in a learned second language. That said, mathematics is not really bound by any type of "reality" either, whereas other fields, even physics, certainly are. A little more reality in math and a little more abstraction in the rest would probably help.