Re:Sony Reveals an Even Bigger Attack on the Internet – the ...
by anigbrowl on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @05:19PM
(#8817061)
If a film isn't available by streaming in a particular country, it's generally because the distributor in that country made exclusivity for a certain period a condition of financing. International presales often provide a significant chunk of production finance, without which the picture doesn't get made in the first place.
For the time being at least, this exclusivity must be assumed to have greater economic value to the individual country's distributor than whatever amount Netflix or one of the streaming or online delivery services is offering.
BTW the proposition about rewarding creatives is in the original article, I'm just not clear on the thinking behind it.
Re:Sony Reveals an Even Bigger Attack on the Internet – the ...
by CamperBob2 on Tuesday December 30, 2014 @07:44PM
(#8817704)
A good point re: presale of international distribution rights. But that system clearly doesn't serve the end user, so you can't be too surprised when the end user finds ways around it. It just goes to show that "Hollywood" thinking isn't a uniquely American hangup.
To make your point about rewarding creators, it's necessary for you to demonstrate that these correspond to lost sales, and you haven't done that.
You do realize that collecting is a goal in itself for a lot of people, right? The guys I hung out with in college made it their sole purpose in life to "own" every piece of software ever written for the Apple II. But that doesn't mean that their actions cost Dan Bricklin, Richard Garriott, and Paul Lutus very much. Probably 95% of the products they pirated, they never even ran.
It's unlikely that the 30,000 people torrenting The Master are devoted but penurious fans of P. T. Anderson. You need to look for alternative explanations.
Also, as others have pointed out, Netflix isn't available in many places outside the US. There is absolutely no one to blame for that but Hollywood. Now that we've seen the intellectual and ethical caliber of the people running the studios, a lot of seemingly-paradoxical things are starting to make sense.