In terms of how this has changed over time: if anything, it used to be much, much worse. For example, Linus' attitude on kernel debugging circa 2000[2] is not merely amateurish, and not merely irresponsible, but actively dangerous. While his attitudes have soften over the years, there still remain striking differences of engineering principle between Linux and other systems -- of which systemd is merely (in my opinion) one particularly egregious manifestation.
In the talk, you said that you and the Illumos community believe that the kernel and the system libraries (e.g. libc) should be inseparable, whereas Linux places a sharp boundary between the two. Why do you believe the Linux approach is suboptimal (except that it makes it easier for you to emulate Linux)? Is there any existing writing on this topic that I can read?
As for illumos, we already have SMF. I have often said that the only thing worse than SMF is not having SMF -- and at some point I intend to tell the full story there: it wasn't always pretty, and it actually makes for an interesting comparison with the systemd adventure.
Regarding UEFI, I wonder if Joyent has enough clout that it could push the relevant suppliers to support coreboot. Edit: I guess the answer is no, since they couldn't interest anyone in Dogpatch.
From a Sun/Illumos aficionado's perspective, has GNU/Linux always been amateur, or is that more recent, e.g. with the intrusion of D-Bus and systemd into servers?