Re:New paper claims that the neutrino is likely a faster-tha...
by bdonlan on Saturday December 27, 2014 @09:22AM
(#8802609)
If they don't use radio technology we'll of course never hear from them - at least not via SETI. So, when it comes to SETI being effective, the interesting case is where the aliens are using radio technology but never advance their modulation technology to the point where the signal is no longer obviously artificial to an observer without knowledge of the coding scheme. It is of course difficult to say whether this is likely to happen; however, it seems contrived for a species to exist that is okay with using math and physics to construct and operate high-power radio transmitters, but refuses (or is unable to) use math to reach the next level of spectral efficiency.
Re:New paper claims that the neutrino is likely a faster-tha...
by CamperBob2 on Saturday December 27, 2014 @07:32PM
(#8804592)
This seems a little ahistorical and antropocentric to me.
No, the principles involved are absolutely universal. They have to deal with the Shannon limit on Altair 4 just like we do here.
This seems a little ahistorical and antropocentric to me.
Ahistorical because even humans have avoided using certain technologies for a variety of reasons -- from certain weapons (chemical/biological, cluster bombs, nuclear weapons, etc) to pesticides, communications technologies, certain programming languages, etc. despite their arguable technological superiority or ability to get the job done.
Anthropocentric because, really, who knows how aliens would think or what they would do? Your argument applies, if it applies at all, to species that think and act much like us. It is debatable whether radically different intelligent (a term which we don't understand even when we apply it to ourselves) species would even understand something as "fundamental" as mathematics the way we do, nevermind actually use technical artifacts in a way recognizable to us.
On the subject of recognizability, could bacteria recognize the humans that they dwell on as intelligent or even living? Can they recognize anything at all? As bacteria are to us, so we may be to alien intelligent life, or even to potentially intelligent life here on earth such as trees, superorganisms like insect or fungal colonies, etc. Organisms that operate at radically different time scales or radically different ways of relating to the world.
Some have argued that the Earth is an organism with agency, or the Internet is one. If that is so, how would we recognize these as such, how would we communicate with them, if it is possible? And if communicating with these on Earth is so unlikely, how much less the likelihood of communicating with beings from other star systems or galaxies utterly unlike that of our own?