Re:Virgin births in animals are no longer rare
by doublextremevil on Friday December 26, 2014 @02:08AM
(#8798325)
Why do you believe the Christian Bible is the Word of God when other texts(The Quran, etc) similarly purport to be the One Truth? These other texts also include "eyewitness testimony."
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Virgin births in animals are no longer rare
by apta on Friday December 26, 2014 @02:13AM
(#8798333)
FWIW, the Quran does not include eyewitness testimony in the sense you are speaking of. It is taken literally as the word of God. Although some parts in it ascribe certain quotes to certain people (e.g. Jesus said so and so, Mary said so and so, etc.), but the witness here is God Himself.
Re:Virgin births in animals are no longer rare
by doublextremevil on Friday December 26, 2014 @02:21AM
(#8798345)
Regardless, eyewitness testimony is not reliable[0]. Many people have claimed to seen UFO's, Aliens, and crimes that people did not commit.
0. http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/do-the-eyes-have-i...
Re:Virgin births in animals are no longer rare
by apta on Friday December 26, 2014 @02:34AM
(#8798362)
Sure, but when investigating events of a certain magnitude, you would more likely have a bigger group of individuals who have witnessed said event. The article references incidents like murder convictions, where it can be easy to mistake one person for another, because they both happen to be of the same race for instance.
In this case; however, we're talking events like person X gave a speech and said Y. This is much more likely to have been heard by many people, so the likelihood of it have happened in the way it was relayed is much higher.
Re:Virgin births in animals are no longer rare
by eli_gottlieb on Saturday December 27, 2014 @01:16AM
(#8801864)
>Sure, but when investigating events of a certain magnitude, you would more likely have a bigger group of individuals who have witnessed said event.
The Torah claims a million witnesses for the revelation at Sinai. I don't see anyone rushing off to become Jewish.
It occurs to me that "number of purported eye-witnesses" may not be a good evidentiary standard.