Re:MOOCs are closed platforms and probably doomed
by dogma1138 on Friday December 26, 2014 @01:14AM
(#8798229)
Good to know, however atm they do offer free access to education for many people who cannot get it or afford it through normal means.
And even the "premium" ones which usually offer full or partial degree accreditation cost significantly less than traditional eduction.
And while many of them might be too "closed" for the usual suspects and champions of freedom it's more to do with the fact that they do offer some certification and credit and so have to be monitored.
I understand why Coursera does for example require sign up and participation in a specified time frame this is so people can go trough the course as a group, study together and learn from each-other just as much as they do from the course.
The courses are also overseen by lecturers which offer help and guidance.
And since you do get a certificate(which value is yet to be determined) they do need to have a strict and repeatable curriculum.
I have a feeling that the writer of this article as many others confuses a MOOC with a library.
A MOOC is not an arbitrary source of information or a "lecture on demand" service, it's an education platform.
This is why the lecture library which Standford uploaded to youtube since like what 2009 is not a MOOC, in fact i would go as far as saying that most "examples" the author provided in his article (although nameless) are not MOOC's..
A "MOOC" is still a course whether it's online or not and to be so it has to provide a structured environment for it's curriculum.
It's should be seen as an evolution of the long distance courses many people have taken for over a century not some podcast you throw on your smart phone or tablet while you take the train to work.
People who treat MOOC's as educational materials and take them seriously benefit from them, people who take them as some instant "smart pill" content that they absorb on the tube can just as well read the free daily papers...
So yeah while bloated smarty pants like the author might bicker and moan about just how bad and doomed MOOC's are I'm sure the tens of thousands of people from Asia, Africa and the Middle East who are lucky enough to have internet access do find them quite useful.
Heck I've seen class A universities steal i mean "borrow" material from Coursera, edX and from Standford (and others) video lectures plenty of times. Especially in new subjects ranging from video game design to information security.
So i guess the material is good enough, and when the educational framework is actually structured people actually benefit from the materials and no only parrot them to feel smarter.
And even the "premium" ones which usually offer full or partial degree accreditation cost significantly less than traditional eduction.
And while many of them might be too "closed" for the usual suspects and champions of freedom it's more to do with the fact that they do offer some certification and credit and so have to be monitored.
I understand why Coursera does for example require sign up and participation in a specified time frame this is so people can go trough the course as a group, study together and learn from each-other just as much as they do from the course.
The courses are also overseen by lecturers which offer help and guidance.
And since you do get a certificate(which value is yet to be determined) they do need to have a strict and repeatable curriculum.
I have a feeling that the writer of this article as many others confuses a MOOC with a library. A MOOC is not an arbitrary source of information or a "lecture on demand" service, it's an education platform.
This is why the lecture library which Standford uploaded to youtube since like what 2009 is not a MOOC, in fact i would go as far as saying that most "examples" the author provided in his article (although nameless) are not MOOC's..
A "MOOC" is still a course whether it's online or not and to be so it has to provide a structured environment for it's curriculum. It's should be seen as an evolution of the long distance courses many people have taken for over a century not some podcast you throw on your smart phone or tablet while you take the train to work.
People who treat MOOC's as educational materials and take them seriously benefit from them, people who take them as some instant "smart pill" content that they absorb on the tube can just as well read the free daily papers...
So yeah while bloated smarty pants like the author might bicker and moan about just how bad and doomed MOOC's are I'm sure the tens of thousands of people from Asia, Africa and the Middle East who are lucky enough to have internet access do find them quite useful.
Heck I've seen class A universities steal i mean "borrow" material from Coursera, edX and from Standford (and others) video lectures plenty of times. Especially in new subjects ranging from video game design to information security.
So i guess the material is good enough, and when the educational framework is actually structured people actually benefit from the materials and no only parrot them to feel smarter.