Re:NSA Reports Improper Surveillance of Americans
by Stratoscope on Thursday December 25, 2014 @05:40PM
(#8797399)
You make some good points, but your argument would be stronger and better received if you left out the personal insults.
Re:NSA Reports Improper Surveillance of Americans
by meowface on Thursday December 25, 2014 @07:09PM
(#8797566)
I think it's perfectly reasonable to use "innocence" as a qualifier for whether or not intelligence should be gathered about a person. Law enforcement uses it, why shouldn't intelligence agencies?
Of course, the problem is that innocence in this case is determined behind closed doors and secret courts, instead of public courts.
Re:NSA Reports Improper Surveillance of Americans
by semi-extrinsic on Thursday December 25, 2014 @09:29PM
(#8797799)
I, for one, think it's awfully naive to think that all collection of information by the intelligence community is an outrage. Authorities collecting information has been going on for about as long as our species has had language.
Re:NSA Reports Improper Surveillance of Americans
by EdSharkey on Friday December 26, 2014 @02:20AM
(#8798343)
Collecting, yes. Storing, indexing, warehousing all meaningful communication, movement, and transactions of all humanity indefinitely - that is the new and condemnable part. I call that absolute power.
Re:NSA Reports Improper Surveillance of Americans
by spacemanmatt on Thursday December 25, 2014 @11:55PM
(#8798099)
I, for one, think it's awfully unconstitutional on the face of it.
Re:NSA Reports Improper Surveillance of Americans
by mjferring on Thursday December 25, 2014 @11:52PM
(#8798095)
Innocence doesn't appear to be a factor, at least according to former Vice President Dick Cheney. In his interview on Meet The Press, he didn't appear to be concerned we tortured innocent people.
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2014/12/15/1351990/-Dick-Chene...
I cannot tell whether you're being paid for by these folk, or just plain politically naive, or suffer from induced helplessness.
Your argument of "outrage" has levels built into it.
L1: collect information
L2: of innocent
L3: americans
L4: properly securing data
L1+L2+L3+L4 => boiling your blood.
For one, why do you even care about L4? Who cares if they secure data properly, they are already doing L1+L2+L3
Why do you care that it is Americans? Would it be better if they focused only on non-Americans, would you have cared less? They are already doing L1+L2.
What is the reason you are hanged up on "innocent"? What does that even mean? Who and how do you determine if someone is innocent? Are you that devoid of critical thinking that you fail to see the rhetoric of "innocents" legitimizes whatever is to be done to those deemed not innocent? They are already doing L1.
They are doing L1. That by itself should have boiled your blood without any regard for L2+L3+L4, which are false arguments inserted into the debate in order to legitimize the actual assault on human rights under the disguise of "better security" by the same agencies that always turn these kind of tricks time and time again.