News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Docker Image Insecurity by ef4 on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @12:10PM (#8788959)
I keep hearing people ask "why won't they just get the core tech right instead of adding all these tangentially related features?".

If Docker was just an open source project, it could focus on getting the core tech right. But Docker is also a startup, and the startup can't stay differentiated unless they keep adding bells & whistles, all of which stay tightly integrated.

See also "Why there is no Rails Inc" (http://david.heinemeierhansson.com/posts/6-why-theres-no-rai...)

Re:Docker Image Insecurity by tinco on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @12:47PM (#8789142)
Let's be real here. If Docker was 'just' an open source project, it would move at 50% of the pace and security issues like this would still not be solved. It's crazy to assume that if it were an open source project it would somehow get the core right faster or not expand on its ambitions.

If it were just an open source project, it could focus on nothing, because Solomon would be working on something else that would actually pay his bills.

It's just a young project with a huge interaction surface, they're trying to please a lot of people in a very small amount of time. No reason to panic, just wait for it to get finished.

Also, Docker is an extracted product just like Rails is, and it's not really a framework so I don't think DHH's argument really applies here.

Re:Docker Image Insecurity by tedunangst on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @01:00PM (#8789216)
Regardless of the development model, the correct ordering of implementing a feature like signature verification remains the same.

1. Write code to verify signatures.

2. Write code to print "The image you are pulling has been verified."

Re:Docker Image Insecurity by tinco on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @03:22PM (#8789996)
I wouldn't disagree, obviously someone messed up here. The discussion is more about that some people believe that the fact that his bug is not being solved is a sign that the Docker team lacks focus.
Re:Docker Image Insecurity by tuffle on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @01:02PM (#8789237)
> Let's be real here. If Docker was 'just' an open source project, it would move at 50% of the pace and security issues like this would still not be solved.

That's wild speculation, and the elephant in the room (Linux), while a different beast, is a pretty strong counterexample for how being 'just' open source oesn't doom you to being slow or insecure.

> It's crazy to assume that if it were an open source project it would somehow get the core right faster or not expand on its ambitions.

I don't think it's crazy at all. A (say, community funded) purely open source project has no distractions and has nothing to do but to get the core right. It also has no incentive or reason to expand its ambitions.

Re:Docker Image Insecurity by FooBarWidget on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @03:29PM (#8790030)
You took Linux as an example? It took Linux 10 years (1992-2002 - kernel 2.4) to get to a stage where it's considered widely production-ready in the enterprise. And the phenomenal development rate of the 2.4+ series is thanks to corporate sponsors hiring talented developers to work on the kernel full time.

I can give you a couple of counter-counter-examples.

GIMP has been around for almost 20 years by now, but its development rate is abysmally slow, still faraway from what most people expect from a Photoshop replacement. Its progress since ~2008 hasn't been that big.

GNOME has been around for almost that long too, but it's constantly suffering from lack of man power.

The Sidekiq background worker system for Ruby is open source, but development went much faster ever since the author started monetizing on it by selling commercial licenses.

Nginx is also open source. They have much more development power now that they are a business and have a source of income. Before, it was just Igor working on it whenever he had time when he's off work.

Re:Docker Image Insecurity by jqm on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @01:11PM (#8789285)
"no incentive or reason to expand its ambitions"

with a nod towards systemd.

Re:Docker Image Insecurity by nknighthb on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @03:25PM (#8790011)
Linux is not a counterexample. The only reason it looks different is that the primary gatekeeper and a few key developers are paid jointly and circuitously by the sponsoring companies.
Re:Docker Image Insecurity by rodgerd on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @01:08PM (#8789275)
> Let's be real here. If Docker was 'just' an open source project, it would move at 50% of the pace and security issues like this would still not be solved

Funny, systemd-nspawn just gained the ability to import and run Docker images. Or rather "the best known container solution".

Re:Docker Image Insecurity by chubot on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @03:37PM (#8790076)
I don't believe Docker is an extracted product. They wrote it from scratch and pushed it on the world, without running it in production themselves.

In particular, I don't believe dotCloud ever ran Docker in production / for paying customers. It seems like there were several earlier containerization technologies based on LXC or OpenVZ, but it wasn't Docker per se. They had some domain knowledge from those earlier experiences, but not production quality code.

Re:Docker Image Insecurity by lclarkmichalek on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @12:27PM (#8789041)
It'd be nice if they said that then. Shit like https://twitter.com/solomonstre/status/539527695999049728 make me wonder just how out of touch the docker folk are.
Re:Docker Image Insecurity by tuffle on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @12:39PM (#8789105)
That one seemed pretty ridiculous to me as well. If your project's direction is constant but your user's understanding is changing, then either you're failing to communicate or (worse) your product is actively forsaking its users.
Re:Docker Image Insecurity by oscargrouch on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @12:49PM (#8789163)
I think a good governance model comes from Mozilla; where you have a Org with the open source core binded to it, which owns a Corp that are free to do some monetization efforts to help the Org to be financially healthy and keep moving.

The core managed at the Org will have less marketing bubble-words, lies and hype, so we keep trusting their goals and mission, while the corp can do whatever they want to achieve their distinct goals.

Re:Docker Image Insecurity by 23david on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @12:20PM (#8789008)
The business model seemed clearer before with the commercialized dockerhub. What is the business model with all these new features?

Seems to me that they'll either license tech to enable enterprises to build their own docker platforms, or offer their own hosted platform... dotcloud 2.0

Re:Docker Image Insecurity by ABS on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @12:31PM (#8789064)
pretty clear in Docker Inc CEO words here: https://gigaom.com/2014/12/20/on-docker-coreos-open-source-a...

“The closest analogy I guess I can give you is, for people who think of Docker and containers as a new form of virtualization, so [with] open source we gave away ESX and what we are selling is something akin to vCenter or vSphere.”

Re:Docker Image Insecurity by tuffle on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @12:47PM (#8789143)
Which, if you put the pieces together, clarifies that the purpose of new Docker features is to lasso in fragmentation and make sure you're going to buy their vCenter/vSphere rather than any alternative.

This also clarifies why things like Rocket are the biggest existential threat facing Docker Inc., and why the mud is being slung.

Re:Docker Image Insecurity by ABS on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @12:52PM (#8789179)
well, those are two different things, aren't they? the direction is pretty clear.

On everything else I'm on the fence but so far the 'batteries included, but swappable' motto has been respected: everything new they have done/announced lately is not in Docker core but rather an external project (think: Swarm, Machine, Compose) that uses the public APIs

Re:Docker Image Insecurity by shykes on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @12:55PM (#8789193)
The business model is the same. We are selling cloud services via Docker Hub, in addition to training and support.

All the new features are pure open design, they only exist because users are asking for them and people are sending patches.