Re:Is Homo Economicus a Psychopath?
by AnimalMuppet on Monday December 22, 2014 @04:40PM
(#8785415)
> Permitting large-scale "exploitation" requires large-scale irrationality, wouldn't you think? It's not rational to be exploited...
That assumes that you have a better alternative. My alternative to being exploited by the greedy capitalists is revolution, but for that to work, a bunch of my fellow oppressed have to agree. My decision is (normally) whether to hopelessly revolt and get crushed, or to make the best of it and go along. In that context, going along is probably a rational choice.
> ... and it's really not rational to be in an exploited minority.
Marxism says that the exploited are the majority, not the minority.
Look, I'm not an apologist for Marxism. I don't want a Marxist revolution, and I don't want to live in the aftermath of one. But I think you're a bit mis-characterizing their position. (Once you characterize it accurately, then disagree as much and as eloquently as you please.)
That assumes that you have a better alternative. My alternative to being exploited by the greedy capitalists is revolution, but for that to work, a bunch of my fellow oppressed have to agree. My decision is (normally) whether to hopelessly revolt and get crushed, or to make the best of it and go along. In that context, going along is probably a rational choice.
> ... and it's really not rational to be in an exploited minority.
Marxism says that the exploited are the majority, not the minority.
Look, I'm not an apologist for Marxism. I don't want a Marxist revolution, and I don't want to live in the aftermath of one. But I think you're a bit mis-characterizing their position. (Once you characterize it accurately, then disagree as much and as eloquently as you please.)