News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Homo Economicus a Psychopath? by joshjkim on Monday December 22, 2014 @04:12PM (#8785257)
This reminds of a thought I had a few months ago: how have there not been more thought pieces relating Uber-the-business's recent/relentless PR-debacles to Nietzsche's Ubermensch concept? I guess I'll give it a go.

Uber/Travis and his execs seem to demonstrate the belief that they are "overmen" in that they seem to believe that they transcend the rules of society and are destined to shape society and its values rather than the other way around (probably something not too uncommonly shared with HN readers…).

A few fun/funny/serious examples (in no particular order):

1. They outrightly express resistance to laws-as-is, and regularly threaten to ignore and sometimes do break those regs as necessary to conduct their business / benefit themselves and their consumers.

2. They hire lobbyists and other high-level political actors to change the laws they don't like and/or influence lawmakers - not atypical for a large company, but they did this earlier than most companies at their stage, with much more specific agendas in place and with a lot more PR surrounding it (the last may or may not have been their doing, hard to say). They have a belief (probably well-founded) that they can use the political process to make the law bend to their will. “Creating New Values” as any good uberman should.

3. They call their central system “Godmode” which implies that they, the viewers, are like God (a bit of a stretch I know…couldn’t resist)

4. They are proud that using the data in Godmode they can track, predict and identify specifics of other human being’s behavior.

5. The whole “we’ll pay our own researchers to smear journalists” thing - another good example of Creating New Values and constructing narratives.

6. The general feeling that Uber (perhaps correctly) operates against “states” and “sovereigns” and “systems” more than corporate competitors (who even writes about Lyft anymore these days…)

The funny thing is that after thinking this through, all (good?) CEOs of major corporations basically operate like this (and so do many other tech-leaders - it is often associated with libertarian-leaning individuals like P. Thiel, etc.) - the difference is that Uber (1) has a name that calls it out and (2) seems to be especially prone to doing this in public and (3) sometimes appears to relishes their “overlord-iness” a little too much. You can call it being crass or being honest.

In any case, they seem to be getting hip to the system and playing nice which of course can be viewed as just another level of the game, etc. - still, glad to see them do it because I overall think that playing nice is best (especially when you can afford to do it) and with a $40b val. and a couple billion raised, I think they can spare some good behavior, at least for now =)

Note on Uber: I think Uber is a great business and has a significantly net-positive impact on society, and I reserve judgment w/r/t whether TK and the other Uber execs are good or bad people - I can't conclude they are good because they run a good business, and I can't conclude they are bad because they say stupid things in public.

Note on Nietzche: In Thus Spake Zarathrusa, the "uberman" concept is (maybe) considered a positive that humanity should work towards in the absence of belief in God, and I think it can still be understood as such. The fact that history has attributed some very negative actions to the belief in this concept (Hitler, Leopold & Loeb's murder, etc.) is, in my opinion, not definitive but at the same time not entirely insignificant, but I'm also a Christian that believes in capital-M Morality so I'm biased against nihilism in general.

Re:Is Homo Economicus a Psychopath? by AnimalMuppet on Monday December 22, 2014 @06:56PM (#8786009)
> Note on Nietzche: In Thus Spake Zarathrusa, the "uberman" concept is (maybe) considered a positive that humanity should work towards in the absence of belief in God, and I think it can still be understood as such.

The problem is that, in the absence of God, there is no absolute morality that is not the result of an arbitrary choice. When the "uberman" arises, he/she creates a new morality, which is needed in the morally nihilistic vacuum that arises due to the absence of God. But because there is no objective basis for morality in the absence of God, that means that the new morality is the result of the "uberman's" arbitrary choice. Is that going to be the magic spark that leads us into a golden age? Only if we get very, very lucky in the "uberman's" arbitrary choice.

Re:Is Homo Economicus a Psychopath? by joshjkim on Monday December 22, 2014 @08:33PM (#8786374)
Totally agree - and I think belief in arbitrariness seems to always lead to either (1) self-interested action or (2) indifference to others - in other words, selfishness, either active or passive.

I'll avoid a Christian-love-based-rant here =) Suffice it to say I was trying to be objective/forgiving/understanding of the uberman concept, but end of the day I'm pretty sure it's a bad deal for everyone involved haha

Re:Is Homo Economicus a Psychopath? by jasonisalive on Monday December 22, 2014 @11:21PM (#8786747)
The Übermensch realises that the pre-existing god-based morality was in itelf fully arbitrary, as it was invented by the weak to defend themselves against the predations of the powerful.

There's not really any way to avoid the necessity of making an arbitrary decision about which values to promote and live for, because even to stick with the status quo is an arbitrary decision to live by originally arbitrary values.

Re:Is Homo Economicus a Psychopath? by jqm on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @01:55AM (#8787114)
Good comment. I agree.

There is no way to avoid the necessity of making a value decision. Even if one chooses the "will of god", they still are making an arbitrary choice. (Never mind at this stage in history the vast smorgasbord of "divine wills" to choose from...).

It all comes down to human valuation. Create your own or follow someone else's. Inevitably.

Re:Is Homo Economicus a Psychopath? by joshjkim on Friday December 26, 2014 @02:34PM (#8799981)
Hm, I can't disprove what you are saying outside of my own experience but I'm also not sure you can prove that all value decisions are arbitrary.

Aside from the fact that such conclusion (which I assume is based on logic/rationalism - but you can pretty much sub any other scientific/philosophical concept here) itself appears to be as constructed (aka. arbitrary) as any other value system, I also think that while arbitrariness may be a logical conclusion when viewing experience/existence/etc. in abstraction, I would argue that at the very least, experience/consciousness gives humans some evidence/reason to believe that value decisions are not or may not be arbitrary, and I consider our direct experience/consciousness to be a very significant data set to consider in spite of how non-rigorous it might be. Put another way, through observation I have concluded that while many people do say all value systems are arbitrary, I have yet to see one person who I would say lives their life as if that were actually true - even my most sociopathic friends (dead writers or real people I know haha) appear to have a strong preference for self-preservation or rationalism.

I'm mostly interested in the concept of self-preservation, aka. the assumed value in continuing one's existence in the first place - I would argue that almost everyone I know makes decisions assuming that their life has value, and that such value decision does not feel arbitrary at all even if logically it seems that way - I think this conflict drives a lot of very smart people crazy or at least annoys them, and to me the existence of this conflict is not insignificant.

As I've said before, I started paying attention when was I 14 and I'm 29 now, so my 15 year data set trends strongly as described =) Of course yours or any other persons experience of consciousness may differ greatly, that's the crazy part about it all I guess.

Re:Is Homo Economicus a Psychopath? by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @04:10AM (#8787393)
>The problem is that, in the absence of God, there is no absolute morality that is not the result of an arbitrary choice.

Simply wrong. Morality is either absolute, in which case it binds God Himself in the first place, or it is meaningless, unworthy of being called morality, mere signaling.

Of course, I'm a stark-raving realist on the matter, but it really depends how you define the word. It's only my preference to be realist about everything, to define my words so that they point at things whose existence does not depend on the words.

Re:Is Homo Economicus a Psychopath? by jqm on Monday December 22, 2014 @09:15PM (#8786491)
But when have the gods actually spoken?

Seems likely what we really have in the words of the gods is simply a collection of more uberman psychopathy. Which leads us right back to the inevitability of lack of absolutes.

Maybe we would be better off dealing with this as is?

Re:Is Homo Economicus a Psychopath? by joshjkim on Monday December 22, 2014 @11:22PM (#8786748)
Without getting too cheesy: I think the gods have spoken through the apparently "irrational" existence of (sorry for the cheesiness!) love, which I define as the the active valuing of other life as more valuable than or at least equal in value to your own. While this is a form of selflessness, I actually think this works in conjunction with the basic belief that human beings are ultimately self-interested, because I believe that to recognize value in others beside yourself and act on that recognition is the most fulfilling and self-satisfying thing a human can do.

To me, this weird alignment of the interests of self and other is pretty counterintuitive and only proven through its exercise/practice, but in any case seems pretty magical/mystical/awesome. I think the fact that a good chunk of modern social structure/law/convention is built on the restraint of the self for the benefit of others (which itself translates into net gains for society overall - magic!) is a manifestation of this fact, and also rears its head in Christianity and almost all other religions (though of course like everything in life, the good is mixed in with some fucked up stuff too).

I can’t really say I have evidence for this other than personal observation of contemporary experiences, historical analysis and my own mind’s logic, but based on those it seems to me that (1) people who treat other people poorly or indifferently seem to be relatively unhappy/dissatisfied and do not feel self-realized and feel disconnected/alienated from those around them and still yearn for more power, wealth, etc. even in spite of the fact that they have more than most and (2) people who treat others well seem to be happy and self-realized and connected to those around them and seem to be relatively satisfied with relatively less power and wealth, etc.

Similarly, societies wherein those in power treat people (relatively) fairly seem to thrive more than societies where those in power treat people unfairly - it seems that this also applies in some way to those who hold the power when comparing relative situations: would you rather be [enter name of random hundred millionaire in America] (who owns only a small portion of American wealth) or Mugabe (who owns/controls half of Zimbabwe)? (cherry-picked that one...haha but still, I don't think it's too off-point)

This is of course assuming that being happy, satisfied, connected and self-realized are in fact, things that are good and that people want, but still, it seems to hold true in my mind through my observation and experience - I’d say I started paying attention around 14, and I’m 29 now, so that’s about a 15 year experiment, and it’s been trending pretty steadily in that direction.

Re:Is Homo Economicus a Psychopath? by jqm on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @02:00AM (#8787127)
You make a valid point. Love is a powerful force. And cooperation does seem to overcome competition historically.

But you must admit, there are no shortage of psychopathic uberman talking about love and goodness to further their own ends....

Re:Is Homo Economicus a Psychopath? by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday December 23, 2014 @04:17AM (#8787417)
Just because the whole "Power of Love" and "Power of Friendship" tropes actually work doesn't mean that an ontologically fundamental conscious agent reached into the physical universe and rejiggered bits to make it go that way. It mostly just means that your average "rational" human being is a lot less rational than he thinks he is, because he can't see powerful psychological and sociological forces even when they're at work in and around him.

>This is of course assuming that being happy, satisfied, connected and self-realized are in fact, things that are good and that people want

Unfortunately, we have a society that largely encourages people to want hierarchical domination, when what's actually good for them is all that stuff you said.

Re:Is Homo Economicus a Psychopath? by jasonisalive on Monday December 22, 2014 @07:13PM (#8786073)
They outrightly express resistance to laws-as-is

Here, I found another arrogant law-defying übermensch-wannabe for you: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahatma_Gandhi

Re:Is Homo Economicus a Psychopath? by joshjkim on Monday December 22, 2014 @08:22PM (#8786339)
For sure - Gandhi (and pretty much anyone who we consider to have "changed the world" - MLK, Steve Jobs, etc.) fits a lot of the uberman characteristics - hence my note re: the fact that the uberman is actually viewed as a positive.

Distinction here for me is that Gandhi and/or MLK and/or Pussy Riot relied on and broke certain social rules based on what I consider to be moral abstractions that (I would argue) (1) pre-existed their own thinking and receive validation from a separate pre-existing moral code (love, human rights, spiritual dignity, etc.) and (2) the realization of which benefit others as equally as they would benefit the leader, if not more (Gandhi was, relatively speaking, part of the educated elite, and could have enjoyed a decent life under the status quo).

On the other hand, I would say that ubermen are (at least by FN's definition) wholly the creators of their moralities, and often are opportunistic in how they use moral abstractions, and (most interestingly) often tend toward creating moral systems that coincidentally(?) benefit themselves and those they value at the expense of others (see: Kim Jong Un, Stalin, Ted Cruz...haha).

I'm glossing over some meat about whether moral abstractions can pre-exist a person's understanding of them and what the difference is between benefiting yourself and benefiting others if benefiting others provides you with serious self-benefit, but those are totally separate discussions =)

Re:Is Homo Economicus a Psychopath? by jasonisalive on Monday December 22, 2014 @11:18PM (#8786743)
I think what you're really saying with all those fancy words about pre-existing moral validations (which is really just an argument from authority) is that you agree with Gandhi/MLK/Pussy Riot that the laws they willfully broke were in fact unjust, and the authorities they were fighting against were tyrannical, and their motives were wholesome, whereas you don't feel that the laws Uber willfully breaks are unjust (or perhaps not unjust enough), and the authorities they are fighting are tyrannical etc. etc. - enough to justify their behaviour.

Keep in mind that at the time Gandhi and MLK were acting, the "right-thinking" dominant majority would have had the same reaction to them - sure, the British might not be perfect, but is it really necessary to cause all this awful fuss about it? Why not just work with them and try and be reasonable? Sure, blacks might not have everything the way they'd like it in the South, but let's not get too extreme here people!

Of course now we all know that negotiating with and beseeching the power agents in these cases was never going to work - the British were never interested in giving up their golden goose, and the whites in the South were never interested in treating blacks as equals. These systems had to be fought against and willfully resisted for people to see what happened when those in power asserted their entrenched position, to understand that it was an absurd, unjust, and exploitative power structure shielding itself with flimsy moral justifications. Change required swimming against the tide of social opinion. Of course now it's all very easy to say "well they were right and weren't they wonderful people" and forget the fact that at the time they were hated.

People in the future may well look back at companies like Uber and similarly appreciate the service they did to humanity by fighting incumbent, corrupted institutions, by fighting for the right for people to make their own decisions about the services they purchase, the contracts they enter into, and the risks they are willing to bear. They may well realise that at the time there was no point negotiating or pleading with the various feudal power brokers of the world - these city halls were never interested in giving up their rights to say who was allowed to sell what to whom under what conditions and at what price - they were too corrupted and no longer really existed to serve their putative original purpose.

You might feel like Uber rubs you the wrong way but at the very least you should realise that there is a significant possibility that people in the future will see you as naive and socialised as those who felt distaste and discomfort at Gandhi and MLK. That alone should give you cause to reconsider your position.

Re:Is Homo Economicus a Psychopath? by joshjkim on Monday December 22, 2014 @11:26PM (#8786757)
Hm - ya, I guess I didn't make it clear enough but I think Uber is net-positive to society, to be sure, no questions asked. How many businesses in the past 30 years have created that many $25-$35/hour jobs that allow for huge flexibility to the workforce while simultaneously fulfilling a huge consumer need? Not more than a few, and I think they are all awesome.

This all was more just a thought-experiment and an attempt to draw a connection I found interesting, but not something I necessarily believe at all - see my "Note on Uber" towards the end of the post:

"Note on Uber: I think Uber is a great business and has a significantly net-positive impact on society, and I reserve judgment w/r/t whether TK and the other Uber execs are good or bad people - I can't conclude they are good because they run a good business, and I can't conclude they are bad because they say stupid things in public."