News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Tell me why a room-and-board-and-bandwidth incuba... by wheels on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @12:36AM (#878357)
But this quickly becomes a case of optimizing for the wrong variable -- because it's already become, "How can you find a way for them to stay?" rather than, "How can you find a way for them to be successful?"

I also don't think that you hook up with mentors via teleconferencing. For whatever reason, face to face meetings matter a lot. You don't have dinner with someone via a teleconference. You don't tell stories over beer via a teleconference. There's a rigid formality -- "Why are we having this conversation?" I think mentorship rarely happens within those lines.

One of the comments above talks about the face-to-face networking opportunities. There's a reason he didn't say, "Why would I want that? I can call up people via Skype Video now..." ;-)

Re:Ask HN: Tell me why a room-and-board-and-bandwidth incuba... by stcredzero on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @12:49AM (#878379)
I also don't think that you hook up with mentors via teleconferencing. For whatever reason, face to face meetings matter a lot. You don't have dinner with someone via a teleconference. You don't tell stories over beer via a teleconference. There's a rigid formality --

Well, I don't know about mentoring per se, but if you have an "always on" connection in the workspace, then you leave the situation open for serendipity. What I'm envisioning is just a "serendipity conduit" or maybe "serendipity space." The workspace can become a play-space in the evening or on the weekend. I could even envision communal dinners.

I'm not thinking about people "calling up" other people. I'm thinking of communal spaces with "magic walls."

Re:Ask HN: Tell me why a room-and-board-and-bandwidth incuba... by Vivtek on Tuesday October 13, 2009 @12:45AM (#878371)
optimizing for the wrong variable I agree. If they stay, they'll stay. The idea is to support them, and benefit from it at the same time.

But I stand by my love for the teleconferencing setup in my house. I'm all over that. (Except, of course, that you're right.)