News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What encrypted chat application to choose? by phelmig on Saturday December 20, 2014 @07:12AM (#8776456)
A good start would be EFF's Secure Messaging Scorecard. They measured all existing solutions using 7 security features(from end-to-end encryption to open source and public reviews).

A few solutions fulfill all requirements (e.g. Telegrams code hasn't been publically reviewed while TextSecure was).

One problem is though, that many open source solutions aren't available for iOS due to issues between Apple's ToS and the GPL.

[1] https://www.eff.org/de/secure-messaging-scorecard

Re:Ask HN: What encrypted chat application to choose? by tptacek on Saturday December 20, 2014 @09:54AM (#8776738)
The EFF scorecard is technically unsound and not a good place to start. It actually caused a small controversy among crypto and security people when it was released.
Re:Ask HN: What encrypted chat application to choose? by atoponce on Saturday December 20, 2014 @10:19AM (#8776798)
To clarify, the most criticism that the EFF secure messaging scorecard had was:

* CryptoCat got a perfect rating, despite it's long history of insecurity, attack vectors, and questionable audits.

* Skype got rated more favorably then is likely the truth. It has since been corrected though.

* PGP got buried as a recommendation.

* A good number of tools were missing on initial release.

The big issue with the scorecard is the lack of rigid definitions, such as code audits. Developers will audit and review each other's code all the time. But most won't qualify that as a "security audit". So, does a security audit require a cryptographer to audit the code? A third party security agency? How in depth do audits go? Are there any standards or "best practices" to go by when auditing crypto code, or is it just a rubber stamp?

With that said, it does list (incompletely) a good set of tools that you can investigate, that you may not have heard of.

Re:Ask HN: What encrypted chat application to choose? by tomkinstinch on Saturday December 20, 2014 @10:06AM (#8776761)
So what are your recommendations?
Re:Ask HN: What encrypted chat application to choose? by bostik on Saturday December 20, 2014 @10:25AM (#8776820)
The problem with that report is that it's more of an assessment than a report. EFF didn't (or couldn't) evaluate or grade the technical merits of any of the chat systems. For example, a professional audit was merely a binary state - there either was one, or there was not. The results of the audit were not considered.

There will have to be a more thorough follow-up at some point.