Re:Imagining a society that isn't dominated by police
by krapp on Friday December 19, 2014 @11:21PM
(#8775857)
You appear to be arguing a false dichotomy as well, that there's no middle ground between anarchy and fascism.
Inevitably, complex societies bring the opportunity for people to organize themselves into power structures, and a power vacuum will be filled. People form societies with governments on the premise that having a system of laws and agents to enforce those laws is a better framework to live by than what came before, where rather than a state, the primary force of violent coercion was the family or the church. You can change the name or the scale but the story remains the same - government is not something alien to human nature, it's a part of the way humans try to organize and control their environment, and build on the complexity of the generations prior.
I suppose you could argue that complexity itself is the problem, if government is an implicit evil, then the ability to form governments must also be an implicit evil. But then you have the problem of how to force people to "cooperate and interact with each other" without forming a government if they choose.
Inevitably, complex societies bring the opportunity for people to organize themselves into power structures, and a power vacuum will be filled. People form societies with governments on the premise that having a system of laws and agents to enforce those laws is a better framework to live by than what came before, where rather than a state, the primary force of violent coercion was the family or the church. You can change the name or the scale but the story remains the same - government is not something alien to human nature, it's a part of the way humans try to organize and control their environment, and build on the complexity of the generations prior.
I suppose you could argue that complexity itself is the problem, if government is an implicit evil, then the ability to form governments must also be an implicit evil. But then you have the problem of how to force people to "cooperate and interact with each other" without forming a government if they choose.