Further, I take issue with the whole notion of the United States being a society "dominated by the police." It looks like we have just the right amount[1], so it seems to me that the issue is lack of training, accountability and open reporting combined with effective police review that are likely to be our problems.
1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_number_of_...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_incarcera...
Here's why I believe that: Black folks are arrested at a rate of 2.5 times, or more, that of white folks, despite committing crimes at about the same rate as white folks (actually, for some classes of crime, such as marijuana use, whites commit crime at a higher rate). This tells me that police exercise discretion when making arrests. And, were they to exercise that discretion equally across races, there would be either a lot fewer or a lot more arrests, and a lot fewer or a lot more people being imprisoned.
In short, to put it into language that HN folks will understand, it is like a sales funnel. Police are an early stage in the funnel for filling prisons, and every stage in the funnel plays a role in the prison industrial complex.
Sources on the 2.5, or higher, number (any time race comes up as a factor, someone will challenge it...so, preemptive response):
http://www.thenation.com/article/176915/scandal-racist-marij...
http://atlantablackstar.com/2014/11/20/usa-today-finds-black...
http://www.cnn.com/2013/06/05/us/us-race-marijuana-arrests/i...
http://www.hrw.org/news/2009/03/02/us-drug-arrests-skewed-ra...
There is some argument to be made that police have evolved alongside the concept of property, in that the role of police has historically been defense of property (where property often included people), and that doesn't always coincide with concern for human lives.
But, I'd rather not get too distracted by what policing looked like hundreds of years ago. What does it look like today? And, is that the best way to protect people from those dangerous groups you speak of (mobs, gangs, etc.)? I honestly don't believe it is. The budgets of major city police forces are absurd, compared to budgets for mental health, rehabilitation, addiction recovery, education, poverty reduction, etc. And, those budgets are padded to the tune of millions of dollars a year from federal sources, including heavily subsidized military equipment (which is a major contributor to the militarization of police forces).
So, how would it affect your opinion on this issue for police to have started as community patrols but turned into something else? Do you assume that because someone (in a pre-democratic era) decided that community patrols were not as effective as appointed police that we should continue to do it the way it's been done for all those years? Is history the right source of inspiration when it comes to use of force?
No thanks. People who provide these services do a better job than I ever will. I'm thankful that they are there, so I can focus all my energy on writing software.