Re:Possible upcoming attempts to disable the Tor network
by boklm on Friday December 19, 2014 @06:14PM
(#8775117)
Because the clients need to get the list of nodes from somewhere.
You can read more about how this works at this URL: https://gitweb.torproject.org/torspec.git/tree/dir-spec.txt
Re:Possible upcoming attempts to disable the Tor network
by catshirt on Friday December 19, 2014 @07:16PM
(#8775325)
just because they need a list of nodes doesn't mean they need to be hardcoded into the client. the other option of course would be to fetch the list remotely.
Re:Possible upcoming attempts to disable the Tor network
by eli on Friday December 19, 2014 @07:35PM
(#8775380)
From what? A directory directory server?
Re:Possible upcoming attempts to disable the Tor network
by MichaelGG on Friday December 19, 2014 @07:44PM
(#8775404)
From any peer? If the list is signed by a majority set of keys then it doesn't matter how it gets distributed.
Re:Possible upcoming attempts to disable the Tor network
by eli on Friday December 19, 2014 @07:48PM
(#8775412)
Isn't finding a peer the original problem?
Re:Possible upcoming attempts to disable the Tor network
by sneak on Saturday December 20, 2014 @01:37AM
(#8776026)
Bitcoin does this by storing a list of DNS hostnames, run by a set of the maintainers, that return periodically-updated lists of peers.
Previously, it also joined an IRC channel and got the list of hostnames from all of the other users in the channel.
Re:Possible upcoming attempts to disable the Tor network
by eli on Sunday December 21, 2014 @11:08AM
(#8780025)
Isn't that just replacing hardcoded IP addresses with hardcoded DNS hostnames? Not much of an improvement.
Re:Possible upcoming attempts to disable the Tor network
by catshirt on Friday December 19, 2014 @08:14PM
(#8775475)
ah, point taken. i didn't think too hard about this apparently. if they had a host serving a list of trusted DAs, that host would be just as valuable a target.
Re:Possible upcoming attempts to disable the Tor network
by MichaelGG on Friday December 19, 2014 @09:08PM
(#8775612)
Any Tor node could be a peer to distributed a signed piece of data.
Re:Possible upcoming attempts to disable the Tor network
by eli on Friday December 19, 2014 @09:48PM
(#8775716)
Yes, but how does one locate a tor node without a directory server?
Re:Possible upcoming attempts to disable the Tor network
by MichaelGG on Friday December 19, 2014 @09:58PM
(#8775737)
Maybe like Bittorrent DHT? The client could keep a cache of other known nodes. You could share them on pastebin versus having them b only hard coded. You could preloaded a hundred peer nodes, instead of 9 master nodes. It doesn't strictly eliminate the problem, but it makes it less likely that one or two governments can just shut it all down.
Re:Possible upcoming attempts to disable the Tor network
by acebarry on Friday December 19, 2014 @10:37PM
(#8775798)
This is kind of how i2p does it. Currently i2p has like 6 "reseed servers" which bootstrap you into finding some other peers. Once you are connected to the network you then can contact "floodfill" servers, which are essentially a distributed form of the directory authorities. Floodfills are autonomously chosen routers on the network, and distribute other nodes to whoever asks.
forgive my ignorance, why would they do this in the first place? fear of MITM?