News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by twelfthnight on Friday December 19, 2014 @02:39PM (#8774048)
In my opinion, if humans were to create robots as intelligent as humans, then those robot would actually be human. What's the difference between passing information via DNA and passing information via some programming code? Are humans from 100,000 years ago less human than humans today, even if we have "improved" slightly due to natural selection?
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by eastbayjake on Friday December 19, 2014 @03:10PM (#8774222)
There's more to being human than intelligence. It's important to remember that sentience actually refers to "the ability to feel sensations," not merely the quality of being an intelligent entity.

Our future robots may be very good at passing information via some programming code... but will they love? Will they be sad? Will they read literature to empathize with the experience of other beings?

I would argue that "being human" is inextricably linked to the isolation of our existence (what David Foster Wallace described as being "marooned inside our own skulls", and why he argued that humans make literature to "give imaginative access to other selves"[1]) and the knowledge that our existence is finite. All humans -- from the cavemen all the way down to you reading this on you computer -- make life decisions knowing that our time on Earth is short. Do you share the same human experience if you know you will live forever?

[1] http://hudsonreview.com/2014/02/on-david-foster-wallaces-con...

Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by r00fus on Friday December 19, 2014 @03:27PM (#8774322)
I'll take the converse argument - there might be more to intelligence than being human (of course, it would be hard for us as "thinking meat" to recognize it). What if the full range of emotions and sensations could be a superset of what humans can actually experience?

It could very well be that we wouldn't even know that kind of intelligence exists - perhaps we're the ones crawling around in the ant farm?

Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by eastbayjake on Friday December 19, 2014 @04:17PM (#8774575)
That's an interesting point! I still think that non-human intelligence would be... non-human. Maybe the Snorgblats will find us in space and ask themselves, "Can these 'humans' share our Snorgblat experience if they can't feel wzinx, yowfli, or even writznok?"
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by IndianAstronaut on Friday December 19, 2014 @05:34PM (#8774962)
>but will they love? Will they be sad? Will they read literature to empathize with the experience of other beings?

Imho, this is basically a signal-response mechanism. You get some 'love' signal inputs and then you can process them into some response which reciprocates that love. It might turn into a hierarchical state system where a continual input of love signals can take a machine to a new state of 'deeply in love'.

Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by terrence_giggy on Friday December 19, 2014 @04:47PM (#8774726)
> Our future robots may be very good at passing information via some programming code... but will they love? Will they be sad? Will they read literature to empathize with the experience of other beings?

That sentence gave me a flashback to my favorite literature reading robot - Orphu of Io (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilium/Olympos)

Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by crazypyro on Friday December 19, 2014 @05:06PM (#8774806)
It depends on your definition of being human obviously. Just another sign of moving goalposts in AI being a huge issue in defining advancements.
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by TheOtherHobbes on Friday December 19, 2014 @02:54PM (#8774137)
Because being human is about a lot more than being intelligent, for whatever definition of intelligence you happen to be using.

Roughly half the human population has below-average intelligence, but carries right on being human regardless.

Inventiveness is possibly more of a species marker than raw IQ.

We're not actually that great at being intelligent. But we're very good at using our intelligence to create experiences, invent new things, and pass both to offspring through indirect external memory structures.

>Are humans from 100,000 years ago less human than humans today, even if we have "improved" slightly due to natural selection?

It may be hard to find anyone who accepts that Paranthropus or Homo Erectus were just as human as modern Homo Sapiens.

Homo Erectus died out around 150kybp, which is close enough, I guess.

Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by twelfthnight on Friday December 19, 2014 @03:06PM (#8774202)
I think this is a good point. I'm out of my depth talking about evolution, so I don't know when we would stop classifying a species as Homo Erectus and start calling it Homo Sapien. That is probably what would say about these robots: they are a new species. But in a lot of ways, since we are products of a natural world, so are they. Just a little more indirectly.
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by stillsut on Friday December 19, 2014 @03:39PM (#8774374)
> I don't know when we would stop classifying a species as Homo Erectus and start calling it Homo Sapien

Unlike other animals where the key factor is morphology (horse -> giraffe) for humans it is the ability to operate as a group and ultimately as a society.

30kya sees hominids adapt to most areas of the world (northern asia, americas) and 10kya civizaltion starts. Although not the traditional biological definition, I would say that's the most salient factor.

Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by devindotcom on Friday December 19, 2014 @02:45PM (#8774084)
Something crafted with a purpose in mind is artificial, something created as a result of random natural processes seems fundamentally different.
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by givan on Friday December 19, 2014 @03:04PM (#8774194)
evolution is not random, it's purpose is to adapt to the environment changes and become better
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by twelfthnight on Friday December 19, 2014 @03:24PM (#8774299)
Well, the process by which genes are passed with genetic mutations is random. If you looked backward in time it looks like animals developed fur to warm themselves. In fact, you're just not seeing all the animals who randomly didn't have fur that froze to extinction.
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by givan on Friday December 19, 2014 @03:30PM (#8774334)
random is just a word for too complex to compute/understand
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by lotsofmangos on Friday December 19, 2014 @04:26PM (#8774625)
No it isn't. Randomness, complexity, computability and understandability are related but distinct concepts.

Some problems are simple and random, some others are complex and deterministic and you also even get some problems that are are simple to state, deterministic, provably uncomputable, yet still understandable, such as the Wang tiling problem.

Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by givan on Friday December 19, 2014 @04:50PM (#8774739)
What problems are simple and random? can you give some examples to prove your argument?
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by lotsofmangos on Friday December 19, 2014 @08:01PM (#8775444)
Emit a single photon at a piece of glass angled at 45 degrees with two detectors, one behind the glass, the other at 90 degrees to the emitter. Which detector is the photon going to trigger?
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by givan on Saturday December 20, 2014 @03:33AM (#8776158)
Quantum mechanics is not simple http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncertainty_principle too complex to compute.
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by lotsofmangos on Saturday December 20, 2014 @10:55AM (#8776900)
The example I gave is not too complex too compute, it is just that computing it gives you a probability function as the result.
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by lotsofmangos on Friday December 19, 2014 @03:54PM (#8774449)
Evolution does not have a purpose and the vast majority of evolution is barely affected by selection pressure and is more down to drift.
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by coldtea on Friday December 19, 2014 @03:38PM (#8774366)
Evolution has no "purpose". That's not what scientists believe about it.
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by higherpurpose on Friday December 19, 2014 @02:52PM (#8774129)
What if we let AI "evolve" on its own within a simulation of life?
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by teraflop on Friday December 19, 2014 @03:00PM (#8774179)
Greg Egan brought up this idea in his novel Permutation City, only to have a change of heart some years later. To quote his FAQ[1]:

> What I regret most is my uncritical treatment of the idea of allowing intelligent life to evolve in the Autoverse. Sure, this is a common science-fictional idea, but when I thought about it properly (some years after the book was published), I realised that anyone who actually did this would have to be utterly morally bankrupt. To get from micro-organisms to intelligent life this way would involve an immense amount of suffering, with billions of sentient creatures living, struggling and dying along the way. Yes, this happened to our own ancestors, but that doesn’t give us the right to inflict the same kind of suffering on anyone else.

> This is potentially an important issue in the real world. It might not be long before people are seriously trying to “evolve” artificial intelligence in their computers. Now, it’s one thing to use genetic algorithms to come up with various specialised programs that perform simple tasks, but to “breed”, assess, and kill millions of sentient programs would be an abomination. If the first AI was created that way, it would have every right to despise its creators.

His more recent story "Crystal Nights"[2] examines the same idea with more focus on the moral implications.

[1]: http://gregegan.customer.netspace.net.au/PERMUTATION/FAQ/FAQ...

[2]: http://ttapress.com/553/crystal-nights-by-greg-egan/

Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by jostmey on Friday December 19, 2014 @02:56PM (#8774154)
There are fundamental differences between a machine designed by the hand of intelligence and that of a biological system. In the case of biology, the design is completely random although it still has a design, as strange as that sounds.
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by rqebmm on Friday December 19, 2014 @03:18PM (#8774259)
There's no "design", there's merely a stable result of random fluctuations in a constrained space. The constraints (i.e. water, oxygen/nitrogen atmosphere, other life forms, etc) are what's key.
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by hawkice on Friday December 19, 2014 @02:55PM (#8774146)
> In my opinion, if humans were to create robots as intelligent as humans, then those robot would actually be human. What's the difference between passing information via DNA and passing information via some programming code?

Well, they would be intelligent in whatever way we mean it. But there's an issue of software -- 'human' implies quite a lot of it (for instance, things like the Westermarck effect, which I don't imagine AIs will have for quite a few reasons), and replicating that is pretty hard, so it's anyone's guess whether we do that or try to find a math-based software foundation.

Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by lotsofmangos on Friday December 19, 2014 @03:18PM (#8774256)
If a dolphin was found to have the same level of reflective intelligence as a human, it would not be a human, it would mean that we would have to extend personhood to include other species.
Re:The dominant intelligence in the cosmos may be artificial by mikeash on Friday December 19, 2014 @04:24PM (#8774608)
Maybe I misunderstand, but you seem to be saying that anything with equivalent intelligence is "human" and that doesn't make any sense to me. If we discover intelligent aliens which evolved completely separately from us, they may be smart but they would never be human. An intelligent machine would be the same.