News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Update on Sony Investigation by mikeash on Friday December 19, 2014 @12:46PM (#8773333)
For the sake of completeness, there's also a fourth:

4. The NSA is incompetent, but correctly concluded that NK is responsible anyway.

I agree that the "incompetent" ones are pretty unlikely. As for choosing between the first two, the big question to me is motive. I've seen plenty of people proposing 2, but I've not yet seen anybody articulate why they would do so. The only reasoning I've seen consists of references to similar false attributions in the past, which certainly has happened, but there are always reasons for it.

So what would the motivation be to lie about it? The Iraq WMD lie was used to justify war, but hacking a movie company won't move the dial on national support for war against North Korea, and there are many better ways to drum up popular support for such a thing. Increased cybersecurity funding? Again, I don't think people will care too much about a movie company as the target. Maybe someone in the US government hated the movie and wanted to sink it, and NK is just a convenient scapegoat? Pretty far fetched. Some other group carried out the hack, but this can't be disclosed somehow? Doesn't make much sense to me.

Unless there's some sort of reasonable proposal for why the US would lie about NK being the source of the hack, it doesn't seem too useful to discuss that angle beyond a basic "and yes, they might be lying for some unknown reason."

Re:Update on Sony Investigation by lotsofmangos on Friday December 19, 2014 @01:31PM (#8773636)
How about, if the people behind the hack are trying to make it seem like it is NK, then investigators may go publicly with that theory while trying to track a culprit, as to announce otherwise may make finding who it is more difficult.