Re:Android: I don't need your permission
by MichaelGG on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @08:40AM
(#8762228)
Could you elaborate how it's a privacy concern? I have to get pretty darn creative to come up with any scenarios.
Re:Android: I don't need your permission
by dllthomas on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @12:13PM
(#8763086)
What makes a privacy concern legitimate, to your mind? It's giving data about a person to a group that otherwise would not have had access to it. It seems first order a privacy concern.
There's also some possibility it could be turned into more sensitive data - if my app tends to be recommended around social circles, and I see two people were on the phone over the same period of time, it's likely they were talking.
Re:Android: I don't need your permission
by MichaelGG on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @03:18PM
(#8764100)
And if a service can reach out to the Internet, it knows my IP can tell where I am. And if it suddenly cuts out after being on a known IP, then maybe I'm going through a local tunnel.
That's what I meant by you have to get really creative to think how this could possibly be impacting. If you have a sandbox, you have to choose which permissions you're going to ask for carefully, to avoid overloading users.
Android made a bad decision by making phone apps needing permission to know if the phone is active, then compounded that by tying it into device ID and who you're calling.
Re:Android: I don't need your permission
by dllthomas on Wednesday December 17, 2014 @07:10PM
(#8765290)
"The privacy concerns are not significant enough to merit demanding permissions" is certainly a defensible position; I'm not sure whether I agree with it, but it's not crazy.
That is distinct, though, from "there is no privacy concern."
It seems like it could be a privacy concern. It seems a common enough need that it probably shouldn't be lumped together with other things, though.