News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by sarahj on Sunday December 14, 2014 @07:24PM (#8750107)
I am not a fan of GLAAD definition. I think it does more harm than good. Gender Dysphoria, the condition associated with transgender individuals, is most likely neurological in nature - that is to say, there are plenty of studies correlating sex-atypical differences in the brain with gender dysphoria. (http://transcience-project.org/brain_sex.html)

Lumping in cross-dressers and run-of-the-mill gender variance denies this very real condition the attention it deserves, it reduces it to a choice. There is nothing wrong with the choice, and people should have the right to express their gender however they choose, I just think that we need to be careful about maintaining a separation between gender dysphoria and gender variance.

On the actual question at hand, clinical intake studies have been pretty consistent in this regard. The number of people who have gender dysphoria that becomes severe enough to prompt treatment (in western European countries) is about 1:10000 (for transgender women) and 1:27000 (for transgender men). (Judge, Ciaran, Claire O'Donovan, and Donal O'Shea. "Gender dysphoria-prevalence and co-morbidities in an Irish adult population." Neuroendocrine Science 5 (2014): 87)

That being said it is difficult to estimate the number of individuals with gender dysphoria who choose not to seek treatment (or those who choose to self medicate). People like John are unfortunate, and a hopefully the bi-product of an age we are on our way out of. That being said, John is clearly not transgender, they may suffer from gender dysphoria, but they are not transgender.

Today we have a much better understanding of gender dysphoria and have a number of long term studies which show hormonal and surgical transitioning to be an effective treatment (e.g Gorin-Lazard, A., Baumstarck, K., Boyer, L., Maquigneau, A., Gebleux, S., Penochet, J.-C., Pringuey, D., Albarel, F., Morange, I., Loundou, A., Berbis, J., Auquier, P., Lançon, C. and Bonierbale, M. (2012), Is Hormonal Therapy Associated with Better Quality of Life in Transsexuals? A Cross-Sectional Study. Journal of Sexual Medicine, 9: 531–541. doi: 10.1111/j.1743-6109.2011.02564.x). I

“First you ask about what sex is on your birth certificate. Then later in the survey you ask, ‘What is your gender?’? - This, of course, doesn't work in first-world countries where gender dysphoria is treated like an intersex condition and the individuals are free to amend their birth certificates.

Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by brighteyes on Sunday December 14, 2014 @07:32PM (#8750135)
> there are plenty of studies correlating sex-typical differences in the brain with gender dysphoria.

There are also plenty of studies showing the opposite, as well as studies showing trans people being, on average, somewhere in between the male and female averages (on the specific area of the brain observed - generally different in each study!). The fact is, we just don't know.

And that's why GLAAD's definition is good. Trans people deserve respect and fair treatment regardless of what causes some people to be trans and others not to be trans. If we find out tomorrow that brain differences can't explain being trans, that doesn't change how trans people should be treated.

And it will probably be quite some time before we have a good answer there. We still don't know why some people are gay and some aren't, for example, and that has received far more research interest. The answer to that question, and to the trans question, will likely be quite complex, scientifically. But ethically, the answer is simple - just treat people nicely regardless.

Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by sarahj on Sunday December 14, 2014 @07:37PM (#8750154)
> There are also plenty of studies showing the opposite, as well as studies showing trans people being, on average, somewhere in between the male and female averages (on the specific area of the brain observed - generally different in each study!). The fact is, we just don't know.

That should have been sex-atypical differences, which would accommodate for the "in-between" studies.

Taken as a whole, the science is pretty clear, when looking at various parts of the brain, patients with gender dysphoria (both prior and after treatment) show differences from cisgender controls, and typically, those differences align with those of their identified gender.

> And that's why GLAAD's definition is good. Trans people deserve respect and fair treatment regardless of what causes some people to be trans and others not to be trans.

These two don't follow each other. Of course transgender people deserve respect and fair treatment, like all people. I just think we have to be careful when we conflate gender variance with gender dysphoria - one is a very evolving cultural concept, the other is a major contributor to suicide in transgender individuals.

Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by Aloha on Sunday December 14, 2014 @08:14PM (#8750254)
After dating a transwoman, I came away with the strong opinion about what being transgender is from a biological/psychological point of view.

What I learned was - it boils down to is a missmatch between the software, and the wetware - the thing is, many people have this, many who are successful and happy in the body they have - but there are some, a minority of those afflicted who simply cannot deal with that missmatch - I don't know why they can't (up bringing, inability to extend beyond classic gender identity, something biological, not really sure) - but whatever the cause, they can't, and those are the folks that generally end up identifying as transgender, and going thru the process of transition to remove the discongruity between the hardware and software.

I don't (well try not to, I'm only human) place a value judgement on it, its about finding your own happy place where you can flower into a good person.

Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by brighteyes on Sunday December 14, 2014 @07:44PM (#8750166)
> Taken as a whole, the science is pretty clear

I don't think it is, unless you pick and choose what you read.

For example,

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transgender#Transsexual_people_...

mentions several studies showing no brain differences.

Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by sarahj on Sunday December 14, 2014 @08:06PM (#8750231)
Yes, there are several studies showing no differences in various task-based studies. There is also at least 1 MRI study I am aware of that didn't find sex-atypical differences, but did find a difference between the subjects and the cisgender controls.

However, and I repeat myself, as a whole - we now at around 30-40 studies most of which fall on the side of there being neurological differences in subjects with gender dysphoria. And in a few key areas we have replication of these findings too.

When you couple this together with long term treatment studies a picture starts to emerge - one of gender dysphoria being an intersex condition which response to hormone therapy and gender confirmation surgery. And most psychologists and endocrinologists now accept that when you take this approach, it is the most successful in producing happy and healthy patients.

Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by brighteyes on Sunday December 14, 2014 @08:45PM (#8750332)
The treatments do not depend on the cause being an intersex condition or a brain syndrome. Modern medical support for trans people helps them far better than anything we had before, but not because it is tied intrinsically to any theory of what causes one to be trans. Instead, the treatment makes sense for someone that feels as their physical form is inappropriate - it helps change that. It doesn't matter why they feel that way.

The danger, as I see it, with your approach is that you predicate society's view of trans people on medical grounds. Being trans is a medical condition, from your perspective. Of course, being trans can be medically relevant, but we aren't talking about that here - we are talking about how society should treat them. For that, the cause is simply irrelevant, and tying it to scientific findings is risky as we don't know what science will find.

Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by ZanyProgrammer on Sunday December 14, 2014 @10:13PM (#8750516)
And its not uncommon in the trans community to tie "biological causes" with "more valid and real." Ultimately I bet gender dysphoria is indeed a biological issue, but it seems presumptuous to think the science is completely settled on it.
Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by ZanyProgrammer on Sunday December 14, 2014 @08:43PM (#8750325)
The problem is that not everyone who is gender dysphoric can transition. That might be a shock to bi-coastal progressives, but for a large chunk of people, stuff like cross dressing might be the only way to deal with it (very, very secretly for people assigned male at birth).
Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by ZanyProgrammer on Sunday December 14, 2014 @08:34PM (#8750301)
"These two don't follow each other. Of course transgender people deserve respect and fair treatment, like all people. I just think we have to be careful when we conflate gender variance with gender dysphoria - one is a very evolving cultural concept, the other is a major contributor to suicide in transgender individuals."

Why can't crossdressers be considered gender dysphoric? It may simply be the way that some people deal with their biological gender dysphoria. Ugh, stupid trans community politics and shit. Yay lets all argue about terminology!

Disclaimer: I am a trans woman.

Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by tjradcliffe on Sunday December 14, 2014 @08:16PM (#8750256)
Those incidence numbers strike me as implausibly low. I happen to know two transpeople fairly well by completely random chance. One is good friend of my (now adult) kids, whose parents are also friends of mine who I met through work, the other is an adult child of my girlfriend.

Unless you hypothesize that for some reason I befriend people who have a vastly increased probability of having trans offspring, numbers like 1:10E4 give me a 1:200000 of being in this position. I would generously assume I know 25 people as well as I know these people, so the probability of finding two in that group who are trans would be 1E-4251E-4*24 = 0.000006. Tiny.

Now, in a world with a few billion adults in it there are going to be a few tens of thousands of people like me, who know more then one transperson from completely unrelated means, but it would be interesting to know if anyone else here does. I'm pretty sure people in my situation are not as rare as those numbers would indicate.

Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by Kalium on Sunday December 14, 2014 @08:24PM (#8750281)
I think it's worth considering that people with non-traditional sexual identities tend to concentrate in certain geographic areas. So perhaps your random selection is taking place over a highly self-sorted population.
Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by ZanyProgrammer on Sunday December 14, 2014 @10:14PM (#8750517)
Yeah, in general I think the HN commentariat is not remotely representative of society as a whole. Especially when it comes to the intersection of tech and sexuality.
Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by gwillen on Sunday December 14, 2014 @09:58PM (#8750490)
I know (at levels varying from 'friend' to 'acquaintance', so the field is more like 100-200 than your 25; but these are all people I have at least conversed with multiple times) two trans men and at least seven trans women (off the top of my head.) These are all people who are, at a minimum, currently taking prescribed hormones corresponding to their self-identified gender.

But I understand that there may be a self-selection effect where a lot of trans women end up in technical fields, so my sample may well be biased.

Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by ZanyProgrammer on Sunday December 14, 2014 @10:11PM (#8750510)
Yeah, I think that trans women might be slightly more prevalent in Silicon Valley than they (we) really should be.
Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by ddingus on Sunday December 14, 2014 @08:18PM (#8750266)
I know a few, and my "know people well" metrics are similar to yours.
Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by spacehome on Sunday December 14, 2014 @08:01PM (#8750212)
> Gender Dysphoria ... is most likely neurological in nature

As opposed to what?

Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by sarahj on Sunday December 14, 2014 @08:05PM (#8750229)
Psychological. Many early theories tended along the line that gender dysphoria was an extension of sexual fetishistic behaviour. We know now this to be very wrong, but there are still many who advocate for this position.
Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by shaftoe on Sunday December 14, 2014 @08:10PM (#8750244)
I'm curious as to the distinction here. Can you explain? Either way sounds like something wired abnormally.

I don't think people necessarily choose their sexual fetishes either, though gender dysphoria strikes me as more of a compulsion than a sexual thing.

Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by sarahj on Sunday December 14, 2014 @08:16PM (#8750260)
Sure. Although it is a vary leaky abstraction :)

We used to consider depression as a psychological phenomena. That is, we used to think that we could make a person think their way out of it. Either though CBT or some other kind of psychological treatment.

Since then we have learned that neurological factors, in particular neurochemistry which are correlated with depression. We now know a person cannot think their way out of depression - we have developed treatments with varying success, although we still have a way to go.

Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by learc83 on Sunday December 14, 2014 @09:41PM (#8750459)
CBT, and medication have fairly similar efficacy rates for treatment of depression.

So it's not true that "We now know a person cannot think their way out of depression."

Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by Amezarak on Monday December 15, 2014 @09:44AM (#8752173)
The argument doesn't make sense in the first place. Neurological problems are expressed psychologically and psychological problems are expressed neurologically. The brain will indeed literally rewire itself based on what you do and think. Which is not at all, of course, to say you can simply wish yourself out of depression. Indeed that's exactly what can make depression such a problem.
Re:Why We Don’t Know the Size of the Transgender Population by bane on Sunday December 14, 2014 @09:38PM (#8750452)
Neurological would mean it's a hardware thing. An analogy would be a CPU that's physically wired wrong. So no matter how good the software is, running it will produce errors.

In the nature vs. nurture debate, this is a nature-side of things.

Psychology would mean it's a software thing. The analogy would be software with some logic errors in it s.t. no matter how good the hardware is, you end up with the incorrect result.

In a nature vs. nurture debate, this is a nurture issue. For example, childhood trauma might turn into some kind of aberrant behavior in adulthood.

Either condition might produce similar or even equivalent results, but the root causes are different and "fixing" them requires different approaches.

And then there might be poor folks with a combination of both factors.