News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bad Microsoft by gaius on Sunday December 14, 2014 @09:33AM (#8748357)
You are 100% correct. It is something that infuriates me when I hear people say they love programming so much they would do it for free. That's great but don't say it out loud. Some people are not motivated by money and that's fine but when you work value is created and it has to go somewhere. Even if you don't need it, take as much money as you can get then just donate it to the local animal shelter. Because if you don't, someone else will, and they will not spend it as wisely as you would.

I see it all the time, silly kids who think there is something pure and noble about giving themselves carpal tunnel, sacrificing their 20s when they should be having fun and forming relationships, sleep deprivation and associated psychological problems, stress, getting burnt out for 0.001% of a company and their boss buying a Porsche and propping up his "habits". Lawyers and doctors are far savvier.

Re:Bad Microsoft by nonymous-- on Sunday December 14, 2014 @09:39AM (#8748372)
Thanks. I wasn't really advocating unionization or really anything in particular, just marveling at how stunningly clueless (or, if you prefer, generous and egalitarian) programmers can be.

The amount of money we collectively leave on the table is staggering.

Re:Bad Microsoft by nsfyn55 on Sunday December 14, 2014 @10:55AM (#8748563)
> The amount of money we collectively leave on the table is staggering.

Right if your goal is to make truckloads of money sure. Not all software professionals ascribe a great deal of value to this end. Many major advances in bringing high-end operating and distributed systems to the masses have come from "Open Source" movements. Is is that hard to imagine a more protectionist, profit-driven software industry where these technologies are shelved in favor of propping up current money makers? In effect denying cheap, high quality solutions to a generation of innovators and start up companies?

As a side note I found your call for unionization to be a flawed comparison. The organizations you've alluded to (AMA and ABA) deal in inelastic goods that enjoy popular legal protections. This is for good reason, no one wants brain surgery from an amateur, but I might give one a shot at standing up my wordpress site.

Re:Bad Microsoft by gaius on Sunday December 14, 2014 @11:31AM (#8748659)
You have managed to completely miss my point. Truckloads of money ARE being made. The only question is who controls them. If a programmer creates a product worth millions but only gets a £20k salary, where has the rest of the money gone? Are you really so altruistic that you would rather your boss and his boss got rich, than taint yourself with money? As I say if you don't want it donate it to good causes but either way YOU should control what happens to as much money as possible, because if you don't, someone else will.
Re:Bad Microsoft by nsfyn55 on Sunday December 14, 2014 @05:40PM (#8749831)
I think it is you that has missed the point. Its not about who gets the money, but whether the initiative would have survived at all in a corporate environment.

Sometimes the only way to jump over the heads of the paymasters is to do something for free.

Re:Bad Microsoft by nl on Sunday December 14, 2014 @07:26PM (#8750113)
my point

Wrong browser window maybe? :)

Re:Bad Microsoft by ufmace on Sunday December 14, 2014 @03:38PM (#8749485)
There's some truth to that, but you have to pay attention to the other factors involved in a typical full-time job. You probably are giving up a lot of money compared to what your work is objectively worth, but not simply to greed and exploitation. At least some of the gap is from the stability and reduction of risk. You know exactly how much money you're going to make every month, and it doesn't change, even if the company/your product isn't doing so well right now. That isn't natural, and it doesn't come for free.

To see the other side of that, you can always work as an independent consultant. You'll probably make more money if you do it well, but you'll have a lot more risk and variability in your income. Can't find a client this month? Tough luck, hope you've got savings. That's what you're giving up money for protection from.

There's also usually a bunch of other stuff provided, which may include sales, advertising, market analysis, customer relations, infrastructure management, etc.

Re:Bad Microsoft by FLUX-YOU on Sunday December 14, 2014 @11:57AM (#8748746)
I think it's an okay attitude to have early in your career. I don't think I would have gotten a foot-in-the-door where I am geographically if my price hadn't been so low. It's very hard to genuinely argue that you're worth $X when you have no professional history. The alternative is essentially socially engineering your way into a position to get the initial experience, and that can be rather underhanded. It's relative though, because even though I am underpaid compared to the USA national average, it's still higher than the median individual incomes for my state. Once I get a year or two under my belt, that experience very quickly pays me dividends by giving me skills and experience that can take me almost anywhere in the world for decent salaries. For the second job, I plan on negotiating much more aggressively. The critical error is maintaining this initial attitude AFTER you have the experience to back up the talk.

The advantage to this attitude is that it appeals to HR and Technical interviewers. You're an upstart with some introductory skills and you probably have the competency to learn on the job and become productive within a decent time frame. It's better than working retail or fast food.

If we move towards an environment more like doctors and lawyers, we'll lose some of the self-taught crowd and probably rely more on paper credentials. I'm sort of talking out of my ass at this point because I've never seen or heard a doctor/lawyer interview for a job, but I imagine it's a little more involved and cautious than our industry's technical tests, puzzles, and quizzes. Our education is also far less involved. Our industry doesn't seem to want to move towards more in-depth technical interviews to establish competency, so unless some heavy regulation comes down the pipe, I really doubt the industry will become professional like the industries of doctors and lawyers

(And besides, why would we? Not every position in the industry will require extensive skills and education. We don't need BAR examines or peer interviews or board examinations or state licenses to build websites)

Another facet of this is that doctors/lawyers are somewhat gated by the time and money costs of education. In 6 months you can crank out one unit of basic programmer through bootcamps or whatever for a fraction of the cost that it takes to produce one unit of doctor or lawyer.

Re:Bad Microsoft by gaius on Sunday December 14, 2014 @01:04PM (#8748972)
This is the argument that photographers and musicians should give their work away for free for the "exposure". But it turns out that converting "exposure" into paying work is quite difficult. Good luck with your negotiations!
Re:Bad Microsoft by shamney on Sunday December 14, 2014 @12:33PM (#8748873)
interviews for graduate legal jobs in biglaw are mostly focused on "fit".