Re:Poll: What do you think of OpenID?
by timdorr on Sunday October 11, 2009 @05:38AM
(#874577)
Well, there should be a breakdown between FB Connect and OpenID. The login flow between those two implementations is drastically different.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
In fact, FB connect is pretty much the antithesis of openid. Openid is open, federated and gives user control. FB connect is closed, centralized and basically allows FB to play big brother.
Actually, Facebook is very prolific in the Open Source world. They're one of the best citizens I've seen: http://developers.facebook.com/opensource.php
In fact, a ton of the code that runs the site itself is fully open source: http://developers.facebook.com/fbopen/ That's mind-blowingly impressive. I still don't believe more people don't know about this or seem to care.
Oh I know and use a lot of their open source software but what has that got to do with fb connect?
"FB connect" is a session management and authentication product from facebook. I find it obnoxious. It is pretty much literally the antithesis of openid. FB open source: good, FB connect: horrible.