News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge: I won't reveal witnesses because Ulbricht could ha... by butwhy on Friday December 12, 2014 @10:06AM (#8740352)
Why don't you think he was? I personally was all-for his cause (and everything silk road stood for), but I think he's probably guilty of the murder thing and they claim evidence to back it up.

Edit: Funny how I'm getting downvotes. Apparently it's soo controversial to make my decision based on evidence. And something that'll he likely be convicted for.

Re:Judge: I won't reveal witnesses because Ulbricht could ha... by lstyls on Friday December 12, 2014 @10:26AM (#8740495)
The prosecution has every incentive to cast Ulbrecht in the worst light possible before the trial begins. Because they're not actually at trial yet, they can make claims that won't actually hold up to scrutiny in court. As others have already pointed out, if he really did order people's murders, wouldn't the prosecution indict him for it?

All that aside, it seems a big leap for Ulbrecht to make from online drug-deal middleman to someone calling out hits on people. He's not Don Corleone or Avon Barksdale, he's some tech kid with really poor judgement. I actually find the government's claim that he tried to hire an undercover as a hitman completely credible. It also seems to speak to the idea that he had no idea what he was doing and was completely out of his element.

Re:Judge: I won't reveal witnesses because Ulbricht could ha... by tptacek on Friday December 12, 2014 @10:31AM (#8740532)
I do not find the idea that some dude sitting on a mountain of Dunning-Krugerrands might write an email allocating some tiny percentage of them to the project of getting rid of someone inconvenient to his business.

I would find the story less believable if it involved Ulbricht actually meeting some shadowy figure in the the parking lot of a Target or whatever. But nobody has alleged that he effectively ordered a killing; he appears to have just had a casual email exchange about it.

The factual complexity of the murder narrative, and the degree of dedicated intent Ulbricht didn't pay to it, seems like good reason not to base the case against him on it.

Re:Judge: I won't reveal witnesses because Ulbricht could ha... by foldr on Friday December 12, 2014 @11:00AM (#8740770)
Enough of the conspiracy theories, please. We already went through all this crap with Hans Reiser (another guy who suffered from "poor judgment"). I have no idea whether Ulbrecht is innocent or guilty, but the most probable reason for the judge's decision is a genuine concern for the witnesses' safety. It's easy to dismiss the risk when it's not your conscience. The judge is probably thinking "Hmm, he's probably not going to have these witnesses killed, but it's going to be a total shit show if he does, so lets err on the side of caution".
Re:Judge: I won't reveal witnesses because Ulbricht could ha... by dietrichepp on Friday December 12, 2014 @10:37AM (#8740587)
> if he really did order people's murders, wouldn't the prosecution indict him for it?

No, that's a non sequitur.

For example, imagine that the prosecution knows that Alice killed Bob, but only because they were illegally tapping Alice's phone lines and the evidence would get thrown out. Or imagine that Alice is in the mafia, and your only witness, Charlie, suddenly went missing.

> he's some tech kid with really poor judgement

History is littered with people who went from "poor judgement" to "murder". To be clear, I'm not calling Ulbricht a murderer. I'm just not convinced that you know him so well that you know what he will and won't do.

Re:Judge: I won't reveal witnesses because Ulbricht could ha... by lstyls on Friday December 12, 2014 @12:37PM (#8741479)
I should clarify, I don't mean poor judgement in the "he's a good kid, he just had poor judgement" sense. He might be a terrible person for all I know. Heck, he probably is. And I wouldn't be surprised if he wanted to murder people. I meant it in the sense that I don't think he is capable of finding someone willing and able.
Re:Judge: I won't reveal witnesses because Ulbricht could ha... by foldr on Friday December 12, 2014 @03:03PM (#8742378)
Surely that pretty much concedes that the prosecution are right. If he wants to kill people then he does pose a significant threat to the witnesses.
Re:Judge: I won't reveal witnesses because Ulbricht could ha... by tinco on Friday December 12, 2014 @10:59AM (#8740763)
It seems a big leap to go from someone who orders a few murders over an anonymous web service paid for with digital currency to being a Don Corleone or Avon Barksdale.

You make it seem like it's some big deal, you could/can literally order a murder in a few clicks on these black market sites.

Re:Judge: I won't reveal witnesses because Ulbricht could ha... by lstyls on Friday December 12, 2014 @11:54AM (#8741155)
> You make it seem like it's some big deal, you could/can literally order a murder in a few clicks on these black market sites.

Please give an example of someone murdered by hire over the internet.

Re:Judge: I won't reveal witnesses because Ulbricht could ha... by canvia on Friday December 12, 2014 @10:15AM (#8740409)
Then why wouldn't they indict him for it? Seems like manipulation of public perception to me.

"If You Care About Internet Freedom, Read About Ross Ulbricht's Silk Road Trial NOW" http://reason.com/blog/2014/12/12/if-you-care-about-internet...

Re:Judge: I won't reveal witnesses because Ulbricht could ha... by tptacek on Friday December 12, 2014 @10:20AM (#8740443)
Because the murder charge is factually complicated, the Silk Road charges are simpler, Ulbricht will serve a long prison sentence if convicted of either set of charges, and introducing the trickier murder charge risks the credibility of the rest of the charges with the jury?
Re:Judge: I won't reveal witnesses because Ulbricht could ha... by tomp on Friday December 12, 2014 @11:08AM (#8740818)
That doesn't sound plausible - US prosecutors are notorious for piling up charges (even when there is little chance they will hold in court), to increase the maximum possible sentence the defendant could server, to make him/her plead guily and settle (e.g. the story of Aaron Swartz).
Re:Judge: I won't reveal witnesses because Ulbricht could ha... by tptacek on Friday December 12, 2014 @11:21AM (#8740897)
This is similar to the logic people applied to the Reiser case and their failure to charge the "serial killer" who "confessed" to Nina Reiser's murder.

The reality is: charges are applied strategically in most federal cases, and, for that matter, witness lists are regularly withheld until trial. The reason this is generating outrage now is because people on HN have a rooting interest in Ross Ulbricht, just like they did in the Reiser case.

Re:Judge: I won't reveal witnesses because Ulbricht could ha... by logfromblammo on Friday December 12, 2014 @12:24PM (#8741376)
Furthermore, if the prosecutor wished it, the grand jury would indict a ham sandwich.

The fact that he was not indicted shows that the prosecutor did not desire for him to be indicted. Given the aforementioned notoriety for throwing everything at the wall to see what sticks, the most likely explanations for a no-bill are (1) the charge can't actually be proven with admissible evidence or (2) the suspect is a cop or (3) the prosecution of the charge would embarrass or otherwise damage the state.

We can probably rule out #2. And by the ham sandwich rule, #1 is only rarely an impediment to indictment. So that leaves #3. The state probably fears what would go public in the discovery phase if they pressed the murder-for-hire charge, and that might affect its position for the other charge.

That should make all of us curious.

Re:Judge: I won't reveal witnesses because Ulbricht could ha... by canvia on Friday December 12, 2014 @10:55AM (#8740725)
It is also possible that the evidence was collected illegally.
Re:Judge: I won't reveal witnesses because Ulbricht could ha... by tptacek on Friday December 12, 2014 @11:26AM (#8740932)
Also true!
Re:Judge: I won't reveal witnesses because Ulbricht could ha... by lsaferite on Friday December 12, 2014 @10:15AM (#8740403)
If they had the evidence you'd think they would charge him with attempted murder.