News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TMSU is a tool for tagging your files by nileshtrivedi on Friday December 12, 2014 @04:54AM (#8739290)
Tags or folders - Aren't both of them mere kludges that we use when search isn't good enough?
Re:TMSU is a tool for tagging your files by wvh on Friday December 12, 2014 @07:49AM (#8739720)
Funny, I'd put it the other way around. Isn't searching what we do when we don't know exactly where something is?

And – admitting I might not be a stereotypical computer user as my files have a high level of organisation – isn't searching the high-level kludge that fails relatively often, especially with hard to parse binary information?

I couldn't imagine relying more on meta-search than knowledge of where my files are located. A tag tool might be nice though, as it enables you to create an alternative hierarchy more suitable to a specific activity without completely abstracting away the physical layout.

Re:TMSU is a tool for tagging your files by jschulenklopper on Friday December 12, 2014 @07:14AM (#8739624)
Tags and folders are a way to structure and organize your stuff, not a kludge. Tagging things, or placing them in containers (possibly also containing other containers) are valuable to add metadata and semantics to the entities.

In a way, placing things in folders is some kind of (hierarchical) tagging, in which those 'tags' (folder and file names) form a traversable path to the entity. Adding tags to entities adds another retrieval path to the objects.

Re:TMSU is a tool for tagging your files by oneeyedpigeon on Friday December 12, 2014 @05:31AM (#8739385)
Folders/directories are a necessity as long as we continue to distribute collections of files the way we do. I'm not sure what github would look like in a world without directories, nor how file naming would work. Do you have a proposal for the issues that doing away with directories brings up?
Re:TMSU is a tool for tagging your files by agumonkey on Friday December 12, 2014 @06:58AM (#8739583)
Folders are only a human factor necessity. Tags forming a graph of related files are more capable, but harder to manage mentally since they can reach any part of the system and cross boundaries.
Re:TMSU is a tool for tagging your files by Yizahi on Friday December 12, 2014 @05:50AM (#8739421)
Search doesn't help when you don't remember filename.
Re:TMSU is a tool for tagging your files by jschulenklopper on Friday December 12, 2014 @07:21AM (#8739643)
Sure it does when the search also investigates the contents of the files.

For example, GMail and Outlook do this for mail items -- you don't need to know the subject, which is comparable to the file name, to retrieve an email -- and Google Desktop Search (discontinued) or Copernic does this for file systems. It is almost as if every system-retrievable item inside a file (e.g. every word in a text document) automatically becomes a searchable item of the file.

Re:TMSU is a tool for tagging your files by Yizahi on Friday December 12, 2014 @10:37AM (#8740590)
The Outlook is a prime example for situation when pure search doesn't help. When I'm looking for some mail 1+ year old I sometimes don't even remember one correct word in it. Then I resort to some kind of tag system - folders, timestamps etc. And some times I don't find it at all.
Re:TMSU is a tool for tagging your files by teach on Friday December 12, 2014 @11:23AM (#8740909)
So far this only works with text-based files. For videos or photos, there's usually not much good metadata or machine-readable file content.
Re:TMSU is a tool for tagging your files by dagw on Friday December 12, 2014 @06:01AM (#8739443)
In an ideal world it should be enough to remember a couple of key words in the file, and possibly some relevant metadata.

In an even more ideal world I should be able to search for "all pictures of my daughter from last Christmas, unless they are out of focus".