Re:The case against human rights law
by danbruc on Friday December 12, 2014 @12:32AM
(#8738712)
I think rayiner just wanted to express that atheism and absolute moral values is a common combination of believes although they are quite incompatible.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
no they aren't.
How do you arrive at absolute moral values if they are not God-given? There are some very real limits like declaring murder a good thing which will just extinct your moral values pretty quickly but besides that? What is fundamentally wrong with killing people with green eyes?
What can you provably say you know? What is irrefutably beyond dispute and based on no suppositions whatsoever?
When has a god ever demonstrably actually ever given any sort of commandments? So where are the absolutes hmmm?
What is fundamentally "wrong" with killing people that have green eyes? I don't know. What is fundamentally wrong with killing people who don't pray like you do?
When you have to ask questions like that, I think you have not followed the issue far enough.
Re:The case against human rights law
by dragonwriter on Friday December 12, 2014 @04:54PM
(#8742947)
> How do you arrive at absolute moral values if they are not God-given?
Its just as possible to assume moral axioms directly as to assume moral axioms prefaced with "God says". You can do this either for detailed rules, or for high-level rules from which detailed rules are derived by reason.
Re:The case against human rights law
by eli_gottlieb on Friday December 12, 2014 @04:46PM
(#8742906)
>How do you arrive at absolute moral values if they are not God-given?
By not defining morals in terms of "what a great authority figure in the sky will reward or punish".
Re:The case against human rights law
by JoeAltmaier on Friday December 12, 2014 @04:50PM
(#8742923)
Or, by convention. They are what makes our society cohesive. Darwinism selects for societies with functional values.