News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by scrollaway on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:26AM (#8735212)
You sure talk a lot about how he was putting malware into people's computer through ads, when he himself said he's glad TPB is gone mostly because of how horrible its ads were[1].

You have a point (to the extent that it can be a point - it's just not really worth talking about anymore): downloading entertainment is not a human right. You make a very poor case of arguing that point.

But I don't think anyone really argues that "downloading movies" is a human right (and those that do are full of it). The problem is very much in reverse. The problem is the lengths that Hollywood and music studios will go to PREVENT people from doing those things. And the only defense is that those things are "morally dubious", and yet a lot of people do it. Hell, it's common knowledge that Spotify did it to get their business started.

So you're arguing the wrong problem. Now you tell me, is it a "right" for those companies to go above and beyond everything to prosecute and intimidate people who want entertainment they provide but are not willing to pay for it? Keeping in mind that: - Said people are not directly costing the companies anything - It's impossible to know whether said people would have paid for the content otherwise - It's impossible to know whether said people would have even known about the content were it not for illegally acquiring it

The following is my subjective opinion: You are a fool if you're angry about piracy on your pet project. You should be glad people go out and look for it. You have an audience.

That audience may not be entirely composed of people willing to pay for your work, but looking for such an audience is not a viable business plan. What you're getting is free advertising. What you're seeing on torrent sites is the very primitive equivalent of what happens on, for example, YouTube where you have channels and networks making more than they can ever dream off ads and sales just because they have the ability to reach so many people at such convenience.

Ears and eyeballs can directly translate to wallets, given the means. But instead of Hollywood/RIAA solving that problem, we have them prosecuting potential fans. We have them shutting down audiences by raiding sites that are full of actual fans. We have them corrupting judicial and political systems one after the other. We have them influencing international treaties and agreements, taking us all for brainless cashcows.

Fuck that.

[1]: http://blog.brokep.com/2014/12/09/the-pirate-bay-down-foreve...

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by patzerhacker on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:36AM (#8735295)
> You are a fool if you're angry about piracy on your pet project.

I'll tell my employees that as our company folds from lack of revenue. I'll tell my wife that as we apply for food stamps. I'll tell the that to the next person interviewing me for a job because people didn't want to pay for the value I provided.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by the8472 on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:48AM (#8735376)
> people didn't want to pay for the value I provided

Well, that simply sounds like a failed product, no? Not everything is successful. Given finite resources (human labor in this case) not everything can be successful.

Just because some people would take it for free does not mean they would take it at the cost it takes to make the product profitable.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by patzerhacker on Thursday December 11, 2014 @12:29PM (#8735953)
The infuriating part is that the people that don't think the software is worth the value they would pay then also feel entitled enough to pay nothing and use it anyway. Don't want to use my software because you don't think it's worth the cost? That's fine, but you don't get to act high and mighty about using it without paying for it.
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by the8472 on Thursday December 11, 2014 @12:45PM (#8736048)
While I can understand the frustration it's not really lost sales, it's just purchases that never would have been made in the first place.

It's the same with music piracy. Sure, one might buy 1 CD. Even 10 CDs. But very few people would buy those 20GB+ of worth of music they hoard on their harddrives. It's something they take for free but would never pay for.

The difference with music is that you can make a partial purchase because the product is sliced into small enough pieces. I may have the whole discography of a band spanning decades, but I only buy one or two of their albums. At least they still get some money that way, so maybe they don't have to feel the same frustration that you do.

In that sense piracy enables some sort of involuntary "set your own price" scheme. But that only works if the product can be sliced down into small enough units enabling the consumers to set their own price.

For software this is more difficult, but not impossible. For example adobe products or microsoft office get pirated in private environments but paid for in commercial settings. The private copies serve to entrench the product in the market, even if they don't generate a direct profit by themselves. So even there is a difference between what people are willing to pay and the retail price of the products.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by patzerhacker on Thursday December 11, 2014 @03:15PM (#8736829)
>While I can understand the frustration it's not really lost sales, it's just purchases that never would have been made in the first place.

This is really splitting hairs. Yes, I acknowledge that it wasn't _just_ piracy that caused the company to shut its doors. But to say that I can't be frustrated about people using the results of my work for free? In what other industry is it acceptable to say, "Yes, we like your product, but no, we're not going to pay, and if you try to make us pay we're going to throw our toys out of the pram about how evil the software developers are!" That's taking it to a whole new level, and that's really the point I was responding to.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by scrollaway on Thursday December 11, 2014 @11:44AM (#8735693)
Let's forget for a moment that, as you tell all those people your sorrows, you will in fact figure out that your product failed not because of piracy but because the product was not giving adequate value for its price...

This is about movies and music at large. Software piracy is a solved problem. In games, the majority of people now use Steam and nobody really cares about the few that look for it on random torrent websites or some such because: 1. They are a much more likely source of malware (you don't just play files, you run executables). 2. Games that care have adopted an online-only DRM model (which has its own problems but that's a story for another thread) 3. A lot of games have an audience comprised entirely of non-paying customers (children without credit cards). Parents are not expected to pirate, and if kids do then no harm done.

In office software, Photoshop and MS Office are the two big names in piracy and both MS and Adobe silently encourage piracy on their products to enforce lock in. And while that sounds scummy when I put it like that, it is an excellent demonstration of what I was mentioning earlier: You have eyeballs/ears which you can easily turn into wallets.

So please, give me a break, your company did not go under because of piracy. And Hollywood/the RIAA have more digits in their bank accounts than total employees.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by patzerhacker on Thursday December 11, 2014 @12:26PM (#8735935)
>Let's forget for a moment that, as you tell all those people your sorrows, you will in fact figure out that your product failed not because of piracy but because the product was not giving adequate value for its price.

That may be, but that doesn't mean that people have the right to unilaterally decide that the price should be zero against the wishes of the seller. They may have the technical ability to do so, but that does not make it moral or ethical to do so in the most general case. I'd like to have a lower electrical bill. Electricity is a non-tangible good, like bits. Does that mean that I should be able to tell the electric company to shove off just because I think they charge too much for electricity? Why is that any different?

If my software fails because nobody wants it at the price it's at then that's a signal that I should lower prices. If my software fails because a large group decides to void the social contract and get my software for free because they disagree with their pricing then I have every right to get angry about it. The software I produce took time and money to produce. It's okay if you don't want to pay for it. Then don't use it. You don't get to have all of the benefit for none of the cost. That's the part that's the most infuriating.

>Software piracy is a solved problem.

How do you make that logical jump?

>You have eyeballs/ears which you can easily turn into wallets.

Not if people are used to and can continue to get the software for free. That relies upon the generosity of some other person down the line to actually pay for the software. Some companies may choose to make that decision. Good for them! But the assumption that all companies will or must or otherwise be ethically or morally bankrupt is a bad one. I'd love to spend all of my time building software for others and let them pay what they want for it, but I have to eat and have a family to support.

Software piracy doesn't hurt big shops or new developers as much as it hurts the smaller guys. Big shops price it into their software costs, and as you said, industry standard software (Office, Photoshop) rely upon it to bring in new users because their target market is saturated. New developers are just happy to get their name out there in many cases - it's a cost of doing business that they can afford.

The small shops in the middle get it the worst. Not enough name recognition to be an industry leader yet enough people that feel entitled to their software for free. The vast majority of them can't win and fold. Is that what meritocracy is? Subject to the whims of an entitled core of freeloaders?

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by scrollaway on Thursday December 11, 2014 @02:17PM (#8736557)
>> Let's forget for a moment that ...

Good thing I said "let's forget that", huh?

> How do you make that logical jump?

Please keep reading?

> The small shops in the middle get it the worst.

Those small shops you keep mentioning, they don't exist anymore. There was a very small decade during which they did exist... shareware shops. Those were really crap. Boy I'm glad they're gone. You know what replaced them? Web apps shops (online-only, no piracy there) and mobile apps shops (where piracy has a much, much higher barrier of entry and is comparatively non-existant).

So as I said, software piracy is more or less a solved problem.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by patzerhacker on Friday December 12, 2014 @10:21AM (#8740452)
>Web apps shops (online-only, no piracy there) and mobile apps shops (where piracy has a much, much higher barrier of entry and is comparatively non-existant).

Well thank goodness you're here to solve all the world's ills! Believe it or not, there are still significant numbers of people that either aren't connected or use software in a situation where they're not connected to the net. That totally screws the usefulness of webapps.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by scrollaway on Friday December 12, 2014 @02:26PM (#8742159)
Nice cynicism, but this is about companies and the effect piracy has on them... not about whether or not web apps are useful for people without internet.
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by 0x5f3759df-i on Thursday December 11, 2014 @11:10AM (#8735505)
Because Hollywood is just barely scraping by from the lack of revenue....
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by vezzy-fnord on Thursday December 11, 2014 @11:07AM (#8735495)
Has there ever really been a documented case of people being driven to poverty as a direct result of their content being put on file sharing networks? It's a very common piece of emotional demagoguery that I see, but I've never seen any sources that substantiate it.
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by psykovsky on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:55AM (#8735416)
That job interview would be your epiphany. That nobody paid for it because you didn't really provide any value at all. Welcome to the real world, where your actions are most likely insignificant and valueless, except for you.