Re:Why have Visual Programming Languages not gone mainstream?
by brudgers on Wednesday December 10, 2014 @05:11PM
(#8732043)
Of the three advantages listed, only the third has much weight because it's hard to see a pictographic language having simpler syntax than Lisp and the most useful software is rarely written by beginners because it usually takes time to develop skill of conjuring up useful abstractions.
Looking at the third advantage, finding logic errors, it is still a bit of a stretch since many pure logic errors can be caught by compilers and tests and the typical pernicious logical errors are related to modeling the domain rather than endless loops or dead code paths.
Finally, not only are words are a really compact way of communicating but the Turing Machine model of computation is based upon alphabets and input strings and thus text is closer to the metal than pictures.
That said, Drakon is an interesting language developed for the Russian space program that leverages graphics in conjunction with text.
Looking at the third advantage, finding logic errors, it is still a bit of a stretch since many pure logic errors can be caught by compilers and tests and the typical pernicious logical errors are related to modeling the domain rather than endless loops or dead code paths.
Finally, not only are words are a really compact way of communicating but the Turing Machine model of computation is based upon alphabets and input strings and thus text is closer to the metal than pictures.
That said, Drakon is an interesting language developed for the Russian space program that leverages graphics in conjunction with text.
http://sage.com.ua/en.shtml?e6l0