News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What do you need that you'd pay a lot for? by sraquo on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @02:51AM (#8721568)
I have three windsport-related ideas for you.

1) weather analysis

I'm a hang glider pilot, but this applies to all wind sports – windsurfing, kiteboarding, paragliding, sailplanes, possibly even surfing and skydiving.

These sports require weather analysis. Is the wind blowing from the right direction? Is the cloudbase high enough?

Some weather analysis tools exist like http://www.xcskies.com/ for hang gliding and paragliding, but they're not perfect to say the least.

I still spend too much time looking at various charts and forecasts in the summer, and then waiting on site once I arrive and the weather conditions aren't right. If you can make me wait less on my precious weekend time, you have my money.

Participants of these sports pretty much accept the current level of technology to be as good as it gets, because there are very few meteorologists who could create new, better weather models, and at the same time be either interested in doing that for free or have the technical and business acumen to make it a business. So pretty much everyone uses the RASP model and weather data off many disparate websites.

---

2) flight instruments

Hang gliders, paragliders and sailpane pilots use special devices that combine a variometer with GPS and some stored map data to record flight paths, show airspeed, descent rate, etc. These are small, like a fat iPhone 6+ with a calculator-style screen.

The company producing the most popular ones is Flytec. I'm not sure how they get away with selling a simple device that runs on two AA batteries for $400-$1000. Maybe they have some key patents... though they are not a monopolist, there's FlyMaster for example. Flytec's devices are pretty much the same as those they were selling 10 years ago, they are cheap to make and should not cost that much.

There's room in the market for a significantly cheaper and/or more magical device. By magical I mean stuff like "go this way to get into the lifting air you've just lost", or "fly faster/slower to maximize glide ratio".

---

3) weather mapping drone

When the wind hits the mountain / ridge at a certain angle, hang gliders, paragliders and sailplanes can easily soar next to that mountain. The wind also needs to be in a certain speed range etc.

Sometime we pilots want to check if that mountain over there could be flyable. It looks like it might be soarable, but to verify this, we need to drive up the mountain and launch a live person in a glider from there. That's a huge waste of time, and because often such roads are privately owned, there's a lot of hassle in getting permission to do that. Landowners are afraid of the liability (which we legally waive but it takes time to explain and verify), and we don't even know if the mountain is soarable at all, we can only guess.

It would be nice if we could just launch a drone which would fly around and record wind direction and speeds at various locations and altitudes.

The same technique could also be used to better understand existing flying sites, OR to find thermals (invisible pockets of uprising air which gliders need to stay up in the air for long period of time). And this is #1 thing we want – more found thermals, more airtime.

So maybe it can be a sort of follow-drone that flies in your general area, telling you where the thermals are. You can tell you're in a thermal once you actually fly into it, but you're descending at 3 ft per second, so the amount of time you can fly searching for thermals is limited.

Because you're flying a glider, the follow-drone can be a glider too with just a small auxiliary engine, you don't need too much battery power.

---

So there you have it. Wind sports are technologically underserved because the market size isn't very big, but the pain is real, and it's #1 reason preventing more people from participating. Maybe some of the weather / hardware solutions you develop might also be applicable in other fields. Maybe you already have a solution that is fairly easily adjustable to wind sports (esp. drones).

Re:Ask HN: What do you need that you'd pay a lot for? by cstigler on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @03:16AM (#8721640)
I'm also a (newbie) hang glider pilot. This idea is a little further out there, but if anybody experienced with aircraft design could build a hang glider that folded into a backpack, it would be huge. Lots of R&D and tiny market, but they would pay tons for it. That convenience is one of the big reasons paragliding is more popular right now.
Re:Ask HN: What do you need that you'd pay a lot for? by sraquo on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @03:33AM (#8721694)
Dammit, how did I forget that. This is more important than anything I've written above. Make a hang glider that packs to 2.5 meters max and doesn't take an eternity to setup and break down (15 minutes max). The performance needs to be somewhere between a modern paraglider and an intermediate hang glider. It would be revolutionary to the sport.

Lack of such hang glider is #1 reason preventing willing people from hang gliding. The popularity of paragliding is proof of that (a paraglider packs into a big backpack). You can't store a hang glider in an apartment because normally it packs into a 5 meter long sausage bag. And I can't even go travel with my hang glider because where do I leave it when I sleep in the hotel? Too risky to leave it on top of car. A small package also allows flying at some ski resorts and other perks.

Designing this hang glider would be primarily solving a configuration problem – how to arrange all required components so that they are foldable and yet strong enough. You have 40 years of HG designs to get inspired from, and don't forget Princeton sailwing, that's an old, under-recognized concept imho.

By the way, hang gliders are small enough that you can truck-test them on the ground to make sure they're strong enough and have proper stability attributes. Unmanned flight testing should also be possible, though not done currently. HGMA even has a list of certification criteria online that you can use as a baseline. What I'm saying is that designing hang glider is easier than designing a Boeing. You do need to know what you're doing, but you don't need a team of PhDs in fluid dynamics and materials science. All important hang glider components are free to use, not covered by current patents.

Re:Ask HN: What do you need that you'd pay a lot for? by annnnd on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @04:15AM (#8721821)
A bit off-topic, but not much: I always wondered why paragliders don't have inflatable compartments like kitesurfing kites do... My theory is that it would help with wing stability.

I have no experience with hang gliders, but as long as you have rigid skeleton you have problems with trasport and storage. Could this skeleton be replaced with an inflatable one?

Re:Ask HN: What do you need that you'd pay a lot for? by sraquo on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @04:50AM (#8721919)
I've actually researched this option. Using compressed air as a structural component is a valid construction technique and could be applied to hang gliders.

It won't work on paragliders because as ram-air wings, they need to collapse when they get unloaded. Otherwise once unloaded the wing will fall over in front of the pilot and probably get entangled with the pilot.

The only heavier-than-air inflatable aircraft currently in production is the Woopy – http://fly.woopyjump.com/ – its design is very unconventional, with continuously running pumps and some weird flight control mechanism. It never passed certification because it's probably not as strong as other hang gliders.

Some potential problems of inflatable hang gliders:

* Ambient air pressure differences at varying altitudes, temperatures, etc.

* Bird attack – sometimes eagles and other birds can get aggressive and try to claw a hang glider. What is a minor annoyance now could be a dangerous flaw if your glider is inflatable.

* A failed inflatable wing can potentially gift-wrap around the pilot preventing them from throwing the reserve parachute in time.

* Less rigidity than metal tubes – danger of buckling at higher speeds / wing-loading.

* There's a certain stigma among HG pilots regarding the concept of inflatable aircraft due to controversy around Woopy and the general idea of riskiness.

However, inflatable aircraft IS a practical strategy. The shortcomings listed above can be overcome given enough effort.

For example, see http://www.prospective-concepts.ch/html/site_en.htm – click on Projects / Air / Pneuwing (and other projects).

Also, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodyear_Inflatoplane

Lastly, in all likeliness the only advantage of an inflatable hang glider would be portability. I don't think it will end up lighter than a tube+fabric construction. The guys from Prospective Concepts seem to believe that they will achieve better glide performance with an inflatable design, but to be honest I doubt that. But then again, they know much more about their technology than I do.

Re:Ask HN: What do you need that you'd pay a lot for? by annnnd on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @05:03AM (#8721964)
Interesting, thanks for the write-up.

About the paragliders: you mean when they land? It is true that the landing becomes more challenging, especially in case of wind (kitesurfers often help each other when entering / exiting). But I guess this could be solved - if nothing else, only the central area could be "reinforced". Let's wait a few years, I'm sure someone will try it. :)

Re:Ask HN: What do you need that you'd pay a lot for? by sraquo on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @05:24AM (#8722023)
No, I mean when the angle of attack of the wing gets too low in flight. This can and does happen due to gusts and thermal activity in the air.

Normally a ram-air paraglider wing would collapse at low angle of attack due to lack of pressure inside the wing (it only works in a certain range of angles of attack), causing both the wing and the pilot to start falling, picking up speed and restoring angle of attack, and re-inflating again. It's kinda hard to explain concisely in more detail.

With a rigid inflated paraglider wing however, if the angle of attack becomes too low, the wing might get unloaded (falls faster than the pilot) and will pitch down even further because that's what a plank wing does in the absence of pendulum weight provided by the pilot. So the wing dives down and gets entangled with either the pilot, the lines or both.

I'm a bit rusty on the exact aerodynamics of paragliders because I only fly hang gliders, but this is roughly what happens.

If you want to know more about how ram-air paraglider wings stay inflated, check out this doc – http://downloads.flyozone.com/pdf/PG/ozone_shark_nose_en.pdf – it talks about a new ram-air intake technology and explains how ram air wings work.

Re:Ask HN: What do you need that you'd pay a lot for? by sraquo on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @08:31AM (#8722564)
I would like to add this document to the case for inflatable hang gliders: http://www.empa.ch/plugin/template/empa/*/107170/---/l=1

Why I am doing this at 5 AM..? I'm insane.

Re:Ask HN: What do you need that you'd pay a lot for? by lazyeye on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @03:00AM (#8721595)
Seabreaze weather site in Australia is something like this for sailing related sports. They have built a solid business on it so I can only imagine a bigger market like the US would be very viable.

Here's the site story (in cartoon form):-

http://www.seabreeze.com.au/Members/Welcome/Cartoon.aspx

And a sample page:-

http://www.seabreeze.com.au/graphs/nsw.asp

Re:Ask HN: What do you need that you'd pay a lot for? by joncalhoun on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @04:39AM (#8721885)
I kiteboard, so I can relate to (1), but the problem I see is that there isn't much of a marketplace effect.

eg - If I am in OBX, NC, I don't need a site that has weather data in CA or FL. There may be slight benefits to this, but I can't think of anything big enough that would make it easy to take over a site that is already popular with the locals of a region.

Am I missing some benefits that come from being larger?

Re:Ask HN: What do you need that you'd pay a lot for? by sraquo on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @05:09AM (#8721978)
Well, basically, weather models are not region-specific, only the actual computations/forecasts are. So it wouldn't make sense to develop an incredibly complex weather model and then only use it in your local region – it would work anywhere, properly configured.

Example of a weather model I'm talking about – RASP http://www.drjack.info/DRJACK/RASP/index.html – many hang gliding clubs run this model on local weather data, e.g. http://www.canadarasp.com/RASPtable.html. That's the best forecasts we can have. Well, that and http://xcskies.com.

Re:Ask HN: What do you need that you'd pay a lot for? by repiret on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @03:10AM (#8721620)
If you think your flight instruments are overpriced, I should show you the bill for replacing the altimeter in my Cessna.

A couple serious questions though:

1. Would glider-pilot software running on a smart phone, possibly with an attached sensor, be a viable replacement for the Flytec devices?

2. How do you feel about angle-of-attack indicators? Do hang gliders have a good place to mount them, and then wire them back to a display?

Re:Ask HN: What do you need that you'd pay a lot for? by sraquo on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @03:46AM (#8721720)
1. Possibly, but iPhone's screen is pathetic in sunlight, and it's speaker is probably not loud enough for variometer beeping. Also, not sure if it has enough battery power for 4 hours of such workload.

2. AoA is too low-level for me personally. I'd rather see my airspeed and glide ratio relative to the air. Hang gliders stabilize themselves at an optimal AoA if you stop providing inputs, but sometimes when I'm desperately trying to reach the landing field I want to know if I should increase or decrease the speed to get there (tradeoff between headwind penetration and sink rate).

Also, personally I'm not going to install anything requiring long wires. There's just too much hassle already in setting up a hang glider... I just want to put the whole device with any sensors in clean airflow and forget about it.

Oh, one more thing I would like is a G-force meter. I'm not supposed to exceed 4G positive on my glider, but I have no idea how it feels like. I'm not going to reach it with normal flying but once I start doing wingovers and loops, I would like to know the numbers I'm getting.

Re:Ask HN: What do you need that you'd pay a lot for? by premyslruzicka on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @05:24AM (#8722019)
https://www.windyty.com/ could help a little
Re:Ask HN: What do you need that you'd pay a lot for? by sraquo on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @05:38AM (#8722061)
Well, it's pretty, but its resolution is not very high. If you zoom in enough you'll see that it doesn't take into account particular mountains and valleys, such terrain features are too small for it. Compare it to http://www.canadarasp.com/RASPtable.html for example (Vancouver area).