Re:Uber banned from operating in Indian capital after rape a...
by rmc on Monday December 08, 2014 @11:25AM
(#8717242)
You can go better than "accusation". Anyone could accuse anyone of anything. But you could set the bar in the middle with "arrested", which is half way between "accusation" and "conviction".
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Uber banned from operating in Indian capital after rape a...
by pc86 on Monday December 08, 2014 @01:16PM
(#8718003)
If on a sliding scale "conviction" is a 100 and "accusation" is a 20, "arrested" falls somewhere between 18 and 22.
Unfortunately there really is no middle ground. You can't point to an event and say that you're __% certain that the accusation is true. So again it boils down to whether you base the decision off of accusations or convictions alone.
As someone stated elsewhere it's not just an ethical decision, either. Economics should play at least a minor role in the decision-making process.
Re:Uber banned from operating in Indian capital after rape a...
by fragsworth on Monday December 08, 2014 @11:42AM
(#8717351)
That's not really in the middle. The only difference between "accused" and "arrested" is that the accuser told the police.
Re:Uber banned from operating in Indian capital after rape a...
by rmc on Tuesday December 09, 2014 @08:26AM
(#8722538)
Yes the accuser told the police, and the police thought there was suffecient reason to arrest the accused. That's the important difference. Sometimes the police are told, and they interview the accused and don't arrest them. Sometimes they do. The police are (in theory) supposed to have standards for who they arrest.
Re:Uber banned from operating in Indian capital after rape a...
by danudey on Monday December 08, 2014 @07:23PM
(#8720157)
In the experience of my friends with regards to sexual assaults in North America, there's a substantial gap between 'accuser told the police' and 'arrested'. I can't imagine it would be any closer of a gap in India.
Re:Uber banned from operating in Indian capital after rape a...
by EpicEng on Monday December 08, 2014 @03:52PM
(#8719107)
Is it? I was accused of a robbery when i was a teenager. I was arrested on another kids claim that i had broken into his garage. No supporting evidence, no other testimony. The charges were dropped, but I was cuffed and taken in.