News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Voting on comments broken ? by jacquesm on Friday October 09, 2009 @11:10AM (#871541)
Thanks for the confirmation, at least I'm not going nuts.

Would it maybe be an idea to drop the buttons if you aren't going to count the votes anyway ? This feels a bit silly.

If it isn't clear which vote buttons work and which ones are just pacifiers then it might lead people to stop voting completely.

Re:Ask HN: Voting on comments broken ? by pg on Friday October 09, 2009 @01:42PM (#872011)
Votes still get registered, even if they don't effect the current score of the item. So it is not quite the same, functionally, as taking away the buttons. Plus if I took buttons away, users would lose the visual indication of what they'd voted on.
Re:Ask HN: Voting on comments broken ? by jacquesm on Friday October 09, 2009 @01:53PM (#872038)
Ok. But it feels inconsistent to see an integer vote count, that goes up when you vote, but after a page refresh those votes are all gone.

Maybe there is a way to at least show them to the user that voted ? That way that feeling would be gone.