Re:Energy Firms in Secretive Alliance with Attorneys General
by gumby on Saturday December 06, 2014 @11:01PM
(#8711197)
> I'm not familiar with how the constitutional federalism rules play out in regards to the behavior of public officials in the states.
That's an interesting question. The constitution says, "The United States shall guarantee to every State in this Union a Republican Form of Government" (not Republican party -- there are no parties in the US constitution). I think most people have taken that to mean no monarchies.
But consent of the governed also rules out corporatist states. However since state attorneys general are either elected directly or appointed by elected officials it may be considered (by transitivity at the very least) that these As-G in fact have the consent of the people to act against their interests.
Re:Energy Firms in Secretive Alliance with Attorneys General
by cylvers on Saturday December 06, 2014 @11:24PM
(#8711238)
How is lobbyists writing letters anywhere near as bad as lobbyists writing bills. Letters have very little legal significance, it's just bureaucratic infighting. Bills are what become law. Attorneys General are charged with prosecuting the people the executive branch wants prosecuted. They are the legal attack dogs of the the government. It is not at all surprising to me that they use any tool that comes to hand in support of their goals.
Re:Energy Firms in Secretive Alliance with Attorneys General
by refurb on Saturday December 06, 2014 @11:09PM
(#8711216)
Letting someone else write a letter doesn't surprise me all that much. I had a friend who was trying to get some federal legislation passed and he pretty much wrote it and handed it to the Congressman's staff. They passed it off as their own.
I'm not familiar with how the constitutional federalism rules play out in regards to the behavior of public officials in the states. It seems to me that it would be tremendously difficult for someone in Oklahoma who opposed this policy to sue the attorney-General over it, for example. The collective suits of the Federal government by multiple states that have proliferated in recent years are also hard to assess legally. Can any of our resident lawyers offer an opinion on this, even a shallow one?