Re:The World's Dumbest Idea: Maximizing Shareholder Value [pdf]
by crazycanuck on Saturday December 06, 2014 @05:11PM
(#8710390)
This isn't really the issue. See my comment above, which in your example translates to the tax rate in company one's scenario being ~2x the rate in company two's.
Let's see what happens to two companies, one of which pays 10% dividend each year, and the other which increases in price 10% each year. Use a tax rate of 15%.
The first company: Every year we get 10% dividend, pay 15% tax on that, have 8.5% post tax dividend. Reinvest in company.
value = initial * (1.085)^nyears
The second company: Every year it increases in value by 10%. If we ever were to sell we would have to pay 15% tax on appreciation.
value = initial + initial * (1.1^nyears-1) * 0.85