Re:Show HN: Code Words, a quarterly publication about progra...
by seanmcdirmid on Saturday December 06, 2014 @05:11PM
(#8710389)
I totally read the article; I'm very surprised it was written by a professional but it wouldn't have changed my judgement of it. I thought it was poorly written and meandering, but I probably should have kept that to myself. I guess we all have different standards.
> Maybe those guys writing software that does things have figured something out as well?
At this point, I really think the article should speak for itself. If you think it says something important or even coherent, then you know, it was for you, not for me.
Re:Show HN: Code Words, a quarterly publication about progra...
by daemonk on Saturday December 06, 2014 @05:39PM
(#8710477)
I don't think you should keep your opinions to yourself. However, when you present your opinions with sarcasm and ad hominem attacks, you are bringing down the conversation to a level that is not conducive to any meaningful discussions. I don't think that was your intention, but I do think it was the result.
I'm rather glad you didn't.
Sean felt justified not reading it because he believed the writer was "a novice", and I think he have acted differently if he knew this was an experienced and successful commercial programmer.
But because he didn't, the rest of us can learn something really interesting: That twenty years of research-experience cannot immediately recognise itself blub to twenty years of commercial-experience.
Maybe those guys writing software that does things have figured something out as well?