Re:Ask HN: Whom do you admire most?
by DanielBMarkham on Friday October 09, 2009 @03:17AM
(#870788)
If only the German generals had cracked down on the street thugs as Deng had put down the Tienanmen protesters
Wow.
So Mao was okay in killing millions, but a few thousand held up in a park constitutes "power-seeking revolutionaries"
In a democracy, you change up who is in power every so often. How could a supporter of frequently-changing power structures be "power-seeking"?
Created the Fox News effect ... It was these hatreds that created World War I
WWI was caused by a lot of pre-planned military manuevers that ran automatically.
The August Madness was real, but don't go blaming the entire war on that.
Hitler came to power as a result of mob violence
Once again, you overstate. Hitler was part of a highly-motivated and organized political party. He was as much part of a mob as he was a ballerina.
FDR provoked Japan into war
What?
It's great to have unusual views. But you are really way on the outside of left field with a lot of these views. It's almost like you already have the answer and are taking a historical hammer and banging away to make the facts fit into your preconceived worldview.
I mean, hey, we all do the same thing, but at some point if you're making a dozen points that are all extremely debatable perhaps your logic isn't on such solid ground, you know?
Wow.
So Mao was okay in killing millions, but a few thousand held up in a park constitutes "power-seeking revolutionaries"
In a democracy, you change up who is in power every so often. How could a supporter of frequently-changing power structures be "power-seeking"?
Created the Fox News effect ... It was these hatreds that created World War I
WWI was caused by a lot of pre-planned military manuevers that ran automatically.
The August Madness was real, but don't go blaming the entire war on that.
Hitler came to power as a result of mob violence
Once again, you overstate. Hitler was part of a highly-motivated and organized political party. He was as much part of a mob as he was a ballerina.
FDR provoked Japan into war
What?
It's great to have unusual views. But you are really way on the outside of left field with a lot of these views. It's almost like you already have the answer and are taking a historical hammer and banging away to make the facts fit into your preconceived worldview.
I mean, hey, we all do the same thing, but at some point if you're making a dozen points that are all extremely debatable perhaps your logic isn't on such solid ground, you know?