I used to be a PhD student (although I dropped out), so I know the ironies of academia too well. But for situations like this, clear communication in advance solves 99% of problems (and this is not specific to academia).
> On the other hand, when other people are involved,
> especially those with "seniority" like P.I.'s and
> advisors, it's no longer obvious what decisions you
> should make.
This problem has been described as "The Tyranny of Structurelessness." [1]"the lack of clear policies and regulations governing academia is one of its greatest advantages, because it gives your mind space to explore, and expands creative freedom."
Are the folks in academia so creatively stunted that they can't find freedom outside of the ivory tower?
It seems like such a silly argument.
what wondrous land do you propose that will support researchers and their desire for a few months out of the year to think about stuff? at most companies, you won't get a few minutes out of the day to do anything other than pack numbers tightly into excel or go to your next standup.
In the corporate world, the failure mode is a crappy job that still pays as well as the AI gig; it's just not as sexy. Then you can slack, learn the skills for your next gig (it's not like you need to be in academe to read papers) and get something better. In academia, the failure mode is being dumped with no money and no reputation in some godforsaken No Country for Old Men reach, being 35 and trying to get an entry-level gig in something.
I wholeheartedly support the concept of slackademia...using idle cycles at work to learn about new, exciting things.
It's entirely possible to leave a paper up in a tab, read it over lunch or just when taking a break from your work, and continue.
This isn't rocket science--nobody is >80% all day erry day in their time usage, regardless of what they claim.
I suggest that both are true, though one or the other may be a bit more efficient for a given situation.
What I dislike is this semi-unspoken assertion by academics that, unless you have the long hours of "freedom" provided only within the ivory tower, people in industry cannot be creative or do useful research. It's insulting to everyone who has made continual progress for mankind while working normal jobs.
my impression of research at facebook/google/microsoft is that they generally hire phds and they generally take phd students as interns, so if you drop out of a phd program, you're not working there (in a research role at least). so you have to finish your phd, then compete with everyone else for those jobs, just like postdocs and professor positions. once there, you have to justify your existence / funding the same way that you do as a professor (go ask people at MSR how this is going for them lately).
A lot of arrogant people, a lot of incompetent people, equal or more politics, very few "hard" problems where hard is defined as "I'm not sure if there is a solution to this, or if there is I have no idea when we will be able to find it, if ever."
It's not about culture, it's about priorities. Academics are interested in solving hard problems or advancing our collective knowledge, not making a bank account higher, not serving ads, and not entertaining people.
Sure, in any large group, there are standout counter examples, but they are the exception, not the rule.
For example, the existence of the Paxos paper didn't mean that most organizations could actually use distributed state machines in real life.
So how about "write the definitive library for X so that nobody needs to write this code again?" That ought to count for something. If you want to see problems solved for real (not just in principle), maybe you're better off in industry.
That sounds like a job for the open-source world.
But for those who yearn for freedom, are capable of building websites or web apps, freelancing might be the path you're looking for (at least, for now).
Entrepreneurs have to make a profit within 3-5 years. Research almost never will -- but when it does, holy crap!
On one hand, the lack of clear policies and regulations governing academia is one of its greatest advantages, because it gives your mind space to explore, and expands creative freedom. If you want to work from 5pm - 3am, nobody will stop you. Ultimately you work for your own advancement, set your own goals, and plan your own schedule.
On the other hand, when other people are involved, especially those with "seniority" like P.I.'s and advisors, it's no longer obvious what decisions you should make. You need to consider more than just yourself, but the lack of regulation creates ambiguity in the "politics" of academia. How do you balance the expectations of those with some power over you, with the expectations you have of yourself? I imagine this question is a source of pressure for many academics, especially those who are extrinsically motivated.