For a number of reasons, no, we don't want PhD students to research whatever random topics pop into their head.
For a start, PhD students don't know how to do research. That's one reason one does a PhD: to learn how to do research. That means listening to your supervisor and working on problems they suggest, at least in the early part of your PhD. I have seen many PhD students, including myself, arrive with half-baked ideas that go nowhere. Learning to formulate a useful research problem is a part of what you are taught.
The second reason is that resources are finite. You don't get to piss around with other people's money anymore than other adults do.
Re:Leaving Academia (2013)
by thekingofspain on Friday December 05, 2014 @10:17AM
(#8704900)
But at the same time, if the supervisor thinks your idea is good in all ways except for likely citation count, then why should you be prevented from researching that?
> I have seen many PhD students, including myself, arrive with half-baked ideas that go nowhere.
Another way to look at it is that failure is a part of learning, and chasing those half-baked ideas can build experience (by finding out what doesn't work).
Re:Leaving Academia (2013)
by Q6T46nT668w6i3m on Friday December 05, 2014 @09:23AM
(#8704594)
Influence matters. And academia attributes influence to merit. But the shape of influence is different from field to field and specialization to specialization. Moreover, it’s difficult to pinpoint a field and specialization where citation impact isn’t limited to “a handful of people.”
"As a PhD student you get to choose some interesting problem and work on that, right? That's what I naively imagined before I started at the institute. Some day at lunch I told my supervisor about this idea I had. We could take his fluid simulation method from computer graphics and apply it to a problem related to molten polymers. There was this experiment by a group of applied physicists that would fit nicely. He asked me how many people would be interested in the problem. Maybe a handful, I said. And then I realized that there was no way I could work on that problem. Success in academia is measured in the number of citations your paper receives. What point is there in writing a paper that is only interesting to such a small audience? To be successful you need to target a large audience, and not just pursue whatever obscure problem takes your fancy."
As a society, don't we want our young academics to be able to pursue their intellectual passions, no matter how obscure? A lot of original research is produced in areas that others have overlooked or considered unimportant. Do we really want a "citation market" to determine whether researchers can pursue their passions?